# Discord, newsletter and Bluesky links: attribute community channels to wishlists

> Why clicks from Discord, newsletters and social apps often look like direct traffic, how to tag each community link, and how to compare channels by wishlists.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-18. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/attribute-community-channels-to-wishlists

Tag every community link, because many apps hide where a click came from. In SparkToro's April 2023 test, 100% of visits from Discord, TikTok, Slack, Mastodon and WhatsApp reached the site as direct traffic. A tagged Steam link keeps the source in Steam's UTM report, and a tagged short link keeps it in your own analytics.

## Key points

- Tag every community link, because SparkToro found that all visits from Discord, TikTok, Slack, Mastodon and WhatsApp showed as direct traffic.
- Put utm_medium=email and the issue in utm_content on newsletter links, so the Steam UTM report shows wishlists per issue.
- Tagged #screenshotsaturday tweets from 9 developers brought 5 wishlists in total, so also measure the wishlist lift on each posting day.

## Why does community traffic look like direct traffic?

Because some apps send no referrer. SparkToro and Really Good Data sent 1,113 visits from 11 networks to test pages. Every visit from TikTok, Slack, Discord, Mastodon and WhatsApp was marked direct. 75% of visits from Facebook Messenger had no referral information either.

Steam has the same blind spot, plus one more: the visitor must be signed in to Steam where the link opens. A Discord link opened in the in-app browser often fails that test.

Sources: SparkToro (April 2023); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

## How should I tag each community channel?

One source per channel and one content value per post or placement. Keep the list short, because Steam hides UTM rows with few visits.

*UTM tags for each community channel.*

| Channel | utm_source | utm_medium | utm_content example |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Discord announcements | discord | community | announcement_date |
| Discord pinned link | discord | community | pinned |
| Newsletter | newsletter | email | issue_12 |
| Bluesky | bluesky | social | post_topic |
| Reddit posts | reddit | social | subreddit_name |

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Manalens channels documentation.

## How do I attribute Discord?

Tag the Steam links you post in Discord, and use a short link for the invite you post elsewhere. Manalens short links can point to discord.gg and discord.com, so a TikTok bio link to your Discord records a link_clicked event with its channel and campaign before the redirect.

Zukowski guessed in 2021 that Discord users are more often on desktop and signed in to Steam, and called it a future experiment. Your own UTM rows for Discord will tell you if that holds for your game. Discord joins themselves are not visible to your analytics. Count clicks on the invite link per source, and compare them with new members per day in your server.

Sources: Manalens short links documentation.

## How do I attribute a newsletter?

Put utm_medium=email on every newsletter link. Manalens places visits with utm_medium email or newsletter, and visits from Substack or beehiiv, in the Email channel. On Steam links, use the issue in utm_content, so the UTM report shows wishlists per issue. Send the Steam link on the day the page goes live, and give that issue its own utm_campaign, so the launch wave does not mix with later issues.

Newsletters are worth the effort. Chris Zukowski calls them the best converting way to keep in contact with fans, and suggests that before your Steam page goes live, every post should point to a newsletter.

Sources: Manalens channels documentation; How To Market A Game (10 March 2025).

## How do I attribute Bluesky and other social posts?

Tag the link, even when the app sends a referrer. Manalens classifies a visit with a bsky.app referrer as Organic Social, but Steam does not see your referrer data at all, only the UTMs on the link.

Do not expect many wishlists per post. In Zukowski's 2021 test, 9 developers posted tagged #screenshotsaturday tweets, and the posts brought 5 wishlists in total. Social posts matter more for reach and for creators who find you there than for direct wishlists.

Sources: Manalens channels documentation; How To Market A Game (14 April 2021).

## How do I compare community channels?

Put three numbers per channel in one table each month: Steam UTM wishlists, clicks on your short links, and installs or conversions from your own analytics.

1. Import the Steam UTM CSV and group by source to get wishlists per channel.
2. Open Links and read clicks per short link for the same dates.
3. Open Attribution and group by channel or source, with game_open or purchase as the conversion.
4. For each channel, compare wishlists per click and installs per click.
5. Ask new Discord members and newsletter readers where they found you, and keep the answers next to the numbers.

- [Game community health metrics: how to measure your Discord, Steam hub and subreddit](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-community-health-metrics)

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Manalens short links and attribution documentation.

## What about people who never click a link?

Most community members will search Steam instead of clicking. For them, use a code or a lift check. A code typed in the game, such as DISCORD10, can be sent as a referral_code_redeemed event and counts in the Referrals channel. A lift check compares wishlist adds on the day of a newsletter or a Discord announcement with the days before.

Sources: Manalens referral codes documentation; Steamworks Wishlists documentation.

## How do I create tagged links for every channel at once?

Use a sheet with one row per channel and placement, then create the links in one step. In Manalens, Bulk create on the Links page takes up to 100 rows from a spreadsheet or CSV, with the target URL, slug, UTMs, label, creator and channel. A bad row does not stop the others.

For a Steam target, the editor warns you when the link breaks a Steam UTM rule, such as a missing utm_source and utm_campaign. Each link also has a QR code you can download as SVG for a booth, a poster or a video.

``` Bulk create CSV (480 is an example app ID)
url,slug,utm_source,utm_medium,utm_campaign,utm_content,label,channel
https://store.steampowered.com/app/480/,dc-pinned,discord,community,demo,pinned,Discord pinned,discord
```

Sources: Manalens short links documentation; Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

## Should Discord or a newsletter be my main call to action?

A newsletter, if you must pick one. Zukowski warns that Discord is a social platform you do not own and can lose, and he recommends a newsletter where you keep the email addresses. Discord is still useful for playtests and feedback.

Measure both anyway. Tag the invite and the signup links per source, and count the wishlists that each brings on the day you post to it.

Sources: How To Market A Game (10 March 2025).

## Which social channels bring the most wishlists?

It differs by game, so measure your own. The Only Way is Down developer posted to TikTok, Reddit, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, Twitter, Tumblr, Threads and Bluesky, and saw by far the most success with Reddit, TikTok and YouTube, in that order. That game is a rage platformer, a genre that clips well.

Use the same tags on every channel for at least a month before you drop one. A channel with few clicks can still bring creators and press who find you there.

- [How to promote an indie game on Reddit: posts and ads](https://manalens.dev/blog/reddit-ads-and-posts-for-indie-games)

Sources: Only Way is Down post-mortem.

## How do I tag my community links?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Create a tagged short link per channel, import the Steam UTM report, and compare clicks, wishlists and installs per channel in one project.

- [UTM builder](https://manalens.dev/tools/utm-builder)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### Why does Discord traffic show as direct?

Discord sends no referrer with link clicks. In a SparkToro test from April 2023, every visit from Discord, TikTok, Slack, Mastodon and WhatsApp showed as direct. A link with UTM parameters keeps the source both in Steam and in your own analytics.

### What UTM tags should I use for a newsletter?

Use utm_source=newsletter, utm_medium=email and the issue in utm_content. In Manalens, utm_medium email or newsletter puts the visit in the Email channel. On Steam links, the same tags show wishlists per issue in the UTM report, so you can compare issues.

### How many wishlists do social posts bring?

Often few. In a 2021 test, tagged tweets from 9 developers brought 5 wishlists in total, partly because most visitors were not logged in to Steam. Measure lift on the posting day as well, because many readers search Steam instead of clicking.

### Can I track Discord server joins by source?

Not directly, because Discord does not send join data to your analytics. Use a tagged short link for the invite in each place you post it, and count clicks per source. Then compare the clicks with the new members per day in your server.

## Sources

- [SparkToro: Dark social falsely attributes web traffic as direct (Rand Fishkin, April 2023)](https://sparktoro.com/blog/new-research-dark-social-falsely-attributes-significant-percentages-of-web-traffic-as-direct/)
- [Steamworks documentation: UTM Analytics (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/utm_analytics)
- [Steamworks documentation: Wishlists (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/wishlist)
- [How To Market A Game: When should I post my Steam coming-soon page? (Chris Zukowski, 10 March 2025)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2025/03/10/when-should-i-post-my-steam-coming-soon-page/)
- [How To Market A Game: How to use Steam's UTM feature (Chris Zukowski, 14 April 2021)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2021/04/14/how-to-use-steams-utm-feature-to-track-the-number-of-wishlists-and-sales-your-marketing-is-generating/)
- [Only Way is Down: post-mortem (developer, read 18 November 2026)](https://onlywayisdown.com/post-mortem/)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [How to track Steam wishlists from creator campaigns](https://manalens.dev/blog/track-steam-wishlists-from-creator-campaigns)
- [Game landing page vs Steam page](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-landing-page-vs-steam-page)
- [Game marketing attribution explained](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-attribution-explained)
- [UTM builder](https://manalens.dev/tools/utm-builder)
- [Game marketing guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/game-marketing)
- [Web analytics for game studios: your website, Steam links and web builds](https://manalens.dev/blog/web-analytics-for-game-studios)
- [Creator campaign dashboard template for Steam games](https://manalens.dev/blog/creator-campaign-dashboard-template)
- [How to track Steam wishlists by source](https://manalens.dev/blog/track-steam-wishlists-by-source)
- [Do you need a website for your indie game? What to put on it](https://manalens.dev/blog/indie-game-website)
