# Do wishlists get old? Wishlist age and launch conversion

> Cohort data from Song of Iron and Cosmoteer on how old Steam wishlists convert, and how to measure conversion by wishlist month with the Steamworks cohort CSV.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-20. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/do-steam-wishlists-get-old

No. Old Steam wishlists convert about as well as new ones. How To Market A Game's cohort analysis of Song of Iron (January 2025) found an average of 8.02% per monthly cohort, with a standard deviation of about 2% and no age pattern. Cosmoteer's month 1 wishlists converted about as well as its month 50 wishlists.

## Key points

- Song of Iron's monthly wishlist cohorts converted at an average of 8.02%, with no clear pattern by wishlist age.
- Cosmoteer kept its Coming Soon page up for about 4.5 years, and its month 1 wishlists converted about as well as month 50.
- After launch, use the MonthCohort column of the Steamworks wishlist CSV to divide each month's purchases by that month's adds.

## Do old Steam wishlists convert worse than new ones?

Not in the published cohort data. Chris Zukowski took Song of Iron, a 2021 game with almost 90,000 wishlists before launch. He joined the Steamworks cohort data, which shows when each buyer had wishlisted, with the wishlist adds per month. Then he charted the share of each month's wishlisters who bought the game.

Monthly rates were mostly between about 5% and 10%, with no clean trend by age. The average was 8.02%, and the monthly rates moved only about 2% around it. One of the best months was June 2020, 1 year and 3 months before launch. The lowest month was the June 2021 Next Fest, at 5.51%.

*Song of Iron: share of each wishlist cohort that bought.*

| Song of Iron wishlist cohort | Share that bought (as of early January 2025) |
| --- | --- |
| February 2020 (page launch, likely friends and followers) | 15.38% |
| March 2020 (14,801 wishlists) | 6.83% |
| June 2021 (Steam Next Fest) | 5.51% (still 991 sales) |
| The month on Popular Upcoming | 9.13% |
| Average of all monthly cohorts | 8.02% |

Sources: How To Market A Game (27 January 2025).

## What did Cosmoteer's 4.5 year campaign show?

The same thing, over a longer time. Cosmoteer had its Coming Soon page from February 2018 and launched in October 2022, with about 144,000 wishlists at launch. Zukowski found that monthly cohort conversion "oscillated between 21% and 15%", and that month 1 converted about as well as month 50. He saw "no indication that the older wishlists converted worse".

In the 2025 article he gives Cosmoteer's average cohort conversion as 19.31%. That is more than twice Song of Iron's 8.02%, which shows that the game matters much more than the age of the wishlist.

Sources: How To Market A Game (6 February 2023); How To Market A Game (27 January 2025).

## Why do recent wishlists sometimes look better?

Because of the window you look at and the marketing near launch. Zukowski shows that if you crop a cohort chart to the last couple of months, it seems to show a "wishlists get old" trend. Across the full history the line is almost flat. He calls the short-window trend a sampling error.

Late marketing also converts well. Wishlists added in the weeks before launch come from players who just saw a trailer, a streamer or the release calendar, and they buy soon. That does not mean older wishlisters stopped caring. Steam emails every wishlister at release, however old the wishlist is.

Sources: How To Market A Game (27 January 2025); Steamworks Wishlists documentation.

## How do I measure conversion by wishlist age for my game?

Use the cohort CSV that Steamworks gives after launch. Valve defines two key columns: MonthCohort is the month in which the player added the game to their wishlist, for example 2021-08-01 for August 2021. DateLocal is the date, in Pacific time, on which the game was bought from the wishlist.

1. After launch, download the wishlist conversion CSV from the Wishlists section of your app in Steamworks.
2. Download your wishlist adds per day, from the same section or from GetAppWishlistReporting in the Financial Web API, and add them up per month.
3. Count the purchases for each MonthCohort.
4. Divide each month's purchases by that month's adds. That is the conversion of the cohort.
5. Chart the rate for every month since the page went live, next to the number of adds, and mark the months with festivals.
6. Read the whole history, not the last few months, before you draw a conclusion. Recent cohorts have had less time to buy, so their rates keep rising for months after launch.

Sources: Steamworks Wishlist Reporting documentation; How To Market A Game (27 January 2025).

## Should I put my Steam page up early, then?

Yes, for most games. The cohort data shows no penalty for early wishlists, and an early page collects more of them. Zukowski also advises against taking a page down to avoid deletes, because time on Steam brings more adds than it loses.

One data point seems to say the opposite. In its October 2025 review of about a year of launches, GameDiscoverCo's selected top converters (each at least 6 times its expected ratio) had been on Steam for 214 days on average before launch, against 411 days for its list of under-converters. Those are small, hit-driven lists, and the time on Steam can reflect many things, such as a fast reveal for a viral game. The lists do not measure how a single wishlist converts by age, so they do not contradict the cohort data.

Sources: How To Market A Game (27 January 2025; 16 September 2022); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).

## What lowers wishlist conversion, if not age?

The game, the price and the timing. In Song of Iron, the visuals drew interest, but the controls and difficulty held sales down, Zukowski writes. GameDiscoverCo found a lower median for games above $10 (0.10x) than for all games (0.15x), and weak conversion for December launches during the Winter Sale. Its under-converters had a median review score of 67% after 7 days, against 91% for the top 20.

There is also a market-wide shift. Zukowski found that games from 2023 to 2025 sold about half as many first-month units per wishlist as games from 2020 to 2022. That is inflation across all wishlists, not ageing of your own.

Sources: How To Market A Game (27 January 2025; 13 October 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).

## How do I see which wishlists convert?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. It syncs wishlist adds, deletes and purchases per day from the Steamworks Financial API (the automatic Steam sync is in early access), and imports the UTM report, so you can compare each month's adds and sources with purchases after launch.

- [Wishlist to sales calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/wishlist-to-sales-calculator)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### Do Steam wishlists expire?

No. A wishlist stays until the player removes it or buys the game, and Steam emails every wishlister at release and for discounts of 20% or more. Cohort studies of Song of Iron and Cosmoteer by How To Market A Game found that old wishlists converted about as well as new ones.

### Is it bad to have a Steam page up for years?

The published data says no. Cosmoteer kept its page up for about 4.5 years, and its month 1 wishlists converted about as well as its month 50 wishlists. An early page collects more wishlists, and Steam emails all of them at launch.

### What is MonthCohort in the Steamworks wishlist CSV?

Valve defines MonthCohort as the month in which a player added the game to their wishlist, for example 2021-08-01 for August 2021. DateLocal is the date, in Pacific time, on which the game was bought from the wishlist. Together they show conversion by wishlist age.

### Why did my Next Fest wishlists convert worse?

It can happen, and the cause is not proven. In Song of Iron, the June 2021 Next Fest cohort had the lowest conversion, at 5.51%, though it still brought 991 sales. That is one game. Measure your own cohorts before you change your festival plans.

### Should I launch soon so my wishlists do not get stale?

No. The cohort data from Song of Iron and Cosmoteer shows no drop in conversion with age. Launch when the game is ready and your wishlist total is high enough. A rushed launch with fewer wishlists and a weaker game is the bigger risk to first-week sales.

## Sources

- [How To Market A Game: Do wishlists get old? (Chris Zukowski, 27 January 2025)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2025/01/27/do-wishlists-get-old/)
- [How To Market A Game: How Cosmoteer's 4.5 year marketing campaign shows that wishlists don't get stale (Chris Zukowski, 6 February 2023)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2023/02/06/how-cosmoteers-4-5-year-marketing-campaign-shows-that-wishlists-dont-get-stale/)
- [Steamworks documentation: Wishlist Reporting (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/wishlist/reporting)
- [Steamworks documentation: Wishlists (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/wishlist)
- [GameDiscoverCo: The state of Steam wishlist 'conversions': 2024-2025 (Simon Carless, 17 October 2025)](https://newsletter.gamediscover.co/p/the-state-of-steam-wishlist-conversions)
- [How To Market A Game: Wishlist inflation is real, but you still need them (Chris Zukowski, 13 October 2026)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2026/10/13/wishlist-inflation-is-real-but-they-are-still-important/)
- [Steamworks documentation: IPartnerFinancialsService (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/webapi/IPartnerFinancialsService)

## Steam data

- [Steam Next Fest: June 2027](https://manalens.dev/steam/events/next-fest-june-2027)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [Steam wishlist deletions: the normal rate](https://manalens.dev/blog/steam-wishlist-deletions)
- [How to read Steamworks wishlist and traffic reports](https://manalens.dev/blog/read-steamworks-wishlist-traffic-reports)
- [What a good wishlist conversion rate is](https://manalens.dev/blog/good-wishlist-conversion-rate)
- [Wishlist to sales calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/wishlist-to-sales-calculator)
- [Steam wishlist guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/steam-wishlists)
- [How to get more Steam wishlists: 9 sources ranked by size and effort](https://manalens.dev/blog/how-to-get-more-steam-wishlists)
- [How many Steam wishlists do you need before launch? Benchmarks by price and genre](https://manalens.dev/blog/how-many-steam-wishlists-before-launch)
- [Road to 10,000 Steam wishlists: a step by step plan with checkpoints](https://manalens.dev/blog/road-to-10000-steam-wishlists)
- [Why did my Steam traffic drop? How to find the cause](https://manalens.dev/blog/why-did-my-steam-traffic-drop)
