# Game ad creative from your trailer and gameplay

> How to cut game ads from trailer and gameplay footage, the sizes Meta, TikTok and YouTube Shorts ask for, and how to measure each creative.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-18. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/game-ad-creative-from-trailer

Cut ads from gameplay, not from the trailer opening. Melos Han-Tani found the Danchi Days trailer had little success as a Reddit ad, while a 6 second 4:5 cut with 0.75 second shots gave a much better wishlist rate (April 2026). Give each creative its own utm_content value and compare cost per wishlist.

## Key points

- Cut game ads from raw gameplay, not the trailer: a 6 second 4:5 Angeline Era video with 0.75 seconds per cut beat the trailer on wishlist rate.
- Export game ads at 9:16 for Reels, TikTok and Shorts and at 4:5 for the Facebook feed, and keep text inside the Reels safe zone.
- Give each ad creative its own utm_content value, then divide ad spend by its UTM wishlists to get a worst case cost per wishlist.

## Why not just run the trailer as an ad?

Because a trailer is made for a person who chose to watch, and an ad must stop a person who scrolls. On a store page, the visitor already wants to know about the game. In a feed, the first second decides if anyone sees the second second.

Indie ad tests point the same way. Melos Han-Tani ran Reddit ads for Danchi Days from December 2025 to April 2026, mostly with images. The trailer had not much success. A short, quick-cut video for Angeline Era had a much better wishlist rate, but videos had a higher cost per click, which so far cancelled the gain.

The This Grand Life 2 case advises in-game screenshots over the trailer, unless the game is action-heavy, and over cover art, which can attract the wrong players.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Game World Observer (31 May 2024).

## Which sizes and lengths does each platform ask for?

Vertical 9:16 for short video feeds, and 4:5 for the Facebook feed. Make one master edit, then export each size, and keep text away from the edges that the app covers.

Instagram Reels covers the top 14%, the bottom 35% and 6% on each side with buttons and the profile icon. Keep the game name and the hook text inside that safe zone. We could not open the official Reddit specification page, so we leave Reddit out of the table.

| Placement | Aspect ratio | Length guidance | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Facebook Feed | 4:5 at 1440 x 1800 | 1 second to 241 minutes | Captions and sound optional but recommended; headline 27 characters |
| Instagram Reels | 9:16 at 1440 x 2560 | 0 seconds to 15 minutes | Safe zone: top 14%, bottom 35%, 6% each side |
| TikTok (non-Spark) | 9:16 recommended, at least 540 x 960 | Up to 10 minutes | 16:9 and 1:1 also accepted; at most 500 MB |
| YouTube Shorts | 9:16 | Under 60 seconds; 10 to 30 seconds for action ads | Only the first 60 seconds play in the Shorts feed |

Sources: Meta Ads Guide (Facebook Feed, Instagram Reels); TikTok Ads Manager Help; Google Ads Help.

## What should the first seconds of an ad show?

The most readable moment of play, with one line that names the hook. On YouTube Shorts, the call to action button shows 3 seconds into the ad for Performance Max, App and Demand Gen campaigns. Google also says sound, as music, voiceover or both, has been shown to increase conversions by over 20%.

Write the hook in words too. The This Grand Life 2 case says the ad title should describe the main hook, not the game name, for example a life sim where your characters have allergies and addictions. Melos Han-Tani saw better click-through rates and costs per click with headlines under 50 characters that did not sound too much like an ad.

Show what the game is. Images that worked for Danchi Days were colorful scenes, cute characters and happy or exciting moments. Key art alone and images with too many characters did not work well, likely because they did not show the game.

Sources: Google Ads Help; Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

## What did published indie campaigns learn about creative?

Clear gameplay images beat key art, short cuts beat full trailers, and targeting moved the numbers as much as the creative did. The table copies each figure from its source.

| Game and channel | Creative | What the source reports |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Danchi Days, Reddit | Mostly images; 3 to 6 ads per ad group | Clicks usually $0.15 to $0.20; often 8 to 10 clicks per wishlist; $1.79 to $1.94 per wishlist |
| Angeline Era, Reddit | 6 second, 4:5 video, 0.75 seconds per cut | Much better wishlist rate than the trailer, but a higher cost per click |
| This Grand Life 2, mostly Reddit | In-game screenshots, hook in the title | $1.1 per wishlist on average, $0.8 to $2.5 by ad group |
| Glyphica, Reddit | One image ad, three targeting groups | Wishlists per tracked visit of 30% niche, 27% broad, 14% desktop only |

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024).

## How do I cut ads from my trailer and gameplay?

Start from raw gameplay, not from the finished trailer, and make several short variants. Each variant tests one idea, so you learn which hook works.

1. List three to five hooks: the moment that shows the genre, the twist, the funniest result, the biggest action.
2. For each hook, pull 6 to 15 seconds of gameplay that shows it in the first second.
3. Cut fast. The Angeline Era test used shots of 0.75 seconds.
4. Export a 9:16 and a 4:5 version. Keep text inside the Reels safe zone.
5. Add one line of on-screen text with the hook, and captions for any voice.
6. Write two or three headlines under 50 characters for each video.
7. Give each creative an ID and use it as utm_content on its link, for example hook_allergies_916.

Sources: Meta Ads Guide; Google Ads Help; Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

## How do I measure which creative wins?

Give every creative its own link, and compare wishlists per tracked visit and cost per wishlist. Put the platform in utm_source, paid in utm_medium, the beat in utm_campaign and the creative ID in utm_content. The Steamworks UTM report then shows one row per creative.

Act on the numbers fast. The This Grand Life 2 case changed ads every two to three days and stopped an ad with zero wishlists from 100 tracked visits. It also found that mobile made 90% of tracked visits and 96% of tracked wishlists, for a PC-only game.

Get the spend from the ad platform. Divide it by the UTM wishlists for a worst case, and by the lift over your baseline for a better estimate. Keep few UTM values, because Steam hides combinations with few visits. A creative that wins on clicks but loses on wishlists is not a winner.

| Number | Formula | Use |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Click-through rate | Clicks / impressions | Does the hook stop the scroll? |
| Wishlist rate | UTM wishlists / tracked visits | Does the ad bring the right players? |
| Tracked cost per wishlist | Spend / UTM wishlists | Worst case, because UTM undercounts |
| Lift cost per wishlist | Spend / wishlists above baseline | Better estimate for the whole campaign |

Sources: Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024).

## Where can I compare creatives by wishlists?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Build one tagged link per creative, import the Steam UTM report, and group Steam rows by content in Explorer. Manalens does not import ad spend, so bring the spend from the ad platform and divide it by the wishlists of each creative.

- [Cost per wishlist calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/cost-per-wishlist-calculator)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### Should I use my Steam trailer as a video ad?

Usually not as it is. A trailer is made for viewers who chose to watch. Melos Han-Tani found the Danchi Days trailer had little success as a Reddit ad, while a 6 second quick-cut video for Angeline Era had a much better wishlist rate. Cut short ads from gameplay instead.

### Which aspect ratio should a game ad use?

Use 9:16 for Instagram Reels, TikTok and YouTube Shorts, and 4:5 for the Facebook feed, as the platform guides recommend. Make one master edit and export both. On Reels, keep text and logos out of the top 14%, the bottom 35% and 6% on each side.

### How long should a game video ad be?

Short. Google recommends under 60 seconds for Shorts ads, and 10 to 30 seconds for ads that ask for an action. The Angeline Era test used a 6 second video. Make several short versions with different hooks, and keep the ones with the best wishlist rate.

### How do I track wishlists for each ad creative?

Give each creative its own utm_content value on a link to your Steam app page, with utm_source and utm_campaign set. The Steamworks UTM report then shows tracked visits and wishlists per creative. Divide the spend from the ad platform by those wishlists to get cost per wishlist.

## Sources

- [Melos Han-Tani: Danchi Days, 3600 wishlists through Reddit Ads (12 April 2026, edited 31 October 2026)](https://buttondown.com/melodicambient/archive/danchi-days-3600-wishlists-through-reddit-ads-was/)
- [Game World Observer: How a solo dev spent $4,365 on paid ads for This Grand Life 2 (31 May 2024)](https://gameworldobserver.com/2024/05/31/paid-ads-steam-wishlists-this-grand-life-2-case-study)
- [Squeaky Wheel: How many wishlists can $500 worth of Reddit ads get you? (Ryan Sumo, 21 June 2024)](https://www.squeakywheel.ph/blog/how-many-wishlists-can-500-worth-of-reddit-ads-get-you)
- [Meta Ads Guide: Video specs for Facebook Feed (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/update/video/facebook-feed)
- [Meta Ads Guide: Video specs for Instagram Reels (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/update/video/instagram-reels)
- [TikTok Ads Manager Help: Video ads specifications (read 18 November 2026)](https://ads.tiktok.com/help/article/video-ads-specifications)
- [Google Ads Help: Your guide to YouTube Shorts ads (read 18 November 2026)](https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/16041697?hl=en)
- [Steamworks documentation: UTM Analytics (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/utm_analytics)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [Steam trailer best practices](https://manalens.dev/blog/steam-trailer-best-practices)
- [TikTok vs YouTube Shorts vs Reels for games](https://manalens.dev/blog/tiktok-vs-youtube-shorts-vs-reels-for-games)
- [Paid ads for indie games: which platform gives the cheapest wishlists](https://manalens.dev/blog/paid-ads-for-indie-games)
- [Cost per wishlist benchmarks by channel and genre](https://manalens.dev/blog/cost-per-wishlist-benchmarks)
- [Cost per wishlist calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/cost-per-wishlist-calculator)
- [Max cost per wishlist calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/max-cost-per-wishlist-calculator)
- [Steam UTM link builder](https://manalens.dev/tools/steam-utm-builder)
- [Game marketing guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/game-marketing)
- [Video game advertising costs for indies: CPM, CPC, CPI and CPW](https://manalens.dev/blog/video-game-advertising-costs)
- [Steamworks data vs your own analytics: what each sees](https://manalens.dev/blog/steamworks-data-vs-your-own-analytics)
- [How to track Steam wishlists from influencer and creator campaigns](https://manalens.dev/blog/track-steam-wishlists-from-creator-campaigns)
- [How to market an indie game](https://manalens.dev/blog/how-to-market-an-indie-game)
