# Game clone protection: AI clones, Steam takedowns and trademarks

> What copyright and trademarks protect in a game, how to report a copy to Valve, which games are easy to clone, and why hiding your demo is the wrong fix.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-19. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/game-clone-protection

Copyright does not protect a game idea, its title or its rules, the U.S. Copyright Office says. It protects your art, music, text and code. So you cannot stop a clone of a mechanic, but you can report copied assets to Valve with its copyright form, and protect your name with a trademark ($350 per class at the USPTO).

## Key points

- Copyright does not protect a game's idea, name or rules, but it does protect its art, music, text and code.
- Report copied art, sound, text or code with Steam's copyright form, and a copied registered name with the Trademark Complaint Form.
- A USPTO trademark costs $350 per class and gives nationwide rights, but it does not stop a clone of your mechanic.

## What does the law protect in a game?

The expression, not the idea. The U.S. Copyright Office says the idea for a game, its name or title, and the methods for playing it are not protected by copyright. Parts of a game can be protected if they contain enough literary or pictorial expression, such as the rules text or the art.

Its Circular 33 adds that copyright excludes any idea, procedure, system or method of operation. Names, titles and short phrases are not protected either. The circular says they may be protected under trademark law instead.

So a clone that rebuilds your mechanic with its own art is hard to stop. A clone that ships your art, sounds, text or code is a copyright case. A clone that uses your registered name or logo is a trademark case.

*Which law covers each part of a game, from U.S. Copyright Office and USPTO pages*

| Part of the game | Protected by | What it means for clones |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Core idea and mechanics | Nothing (not copyright) | Others can make a game on similar principles |
| Rules text, story, dialogue | Copyright | Word for word copies can be reported |
| Art, models, music, sound | Copyright | Copied assets can be reported |
| Source code | Copyright | Copied code can be reported |
| Game name and logo | Trademark, not copyright | Strongest when registered |

Sources: U.S. Copyright Office Games page; U.S. Copyright Office Circular 33.

## How fast do clones appear now?

Within days of a viral post. In August 2026, a prototype video of a game about finding one needle in 5 million pieces of hay went viral. How To Market A Game reports that within a week the developer had a Steam page for Needle In A Haystack Simulator, and clone pages went live the same day. One clone shipped a public demo first, and another released a full game before the original.

Kotaku counted at least fourteen clones by 18 October 2026. One clone developer, NoGlyph, said another clone contained 13 of its classes with the same names and its own error messages word for word. GamesRadar later reported that the accused game appeared to have been removed from Steam.

Some studios changed plans. Digital Sun moved the playtest of its next game, ReVamp, from a public Steam build to its Discord server. It said a large public build months before launch felt like too big a risk.

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 October 2026); Kotaku (18 October 2026); GamesRadar (29 October 2026); Game Developer (19 October 2026).

## What does Valve say about AI clones?

Valve says the best defence is a community and regular updates, not new store rules. At a developer event in Korea in October 2026, Tom Giardino of the Steam business team said Valve does not want to be a gatekeeper that tells developers which tools to use. Game Developer reports that he said complex games are harder to copy.

heise online reports that Giardino called extortion emails, which threaten to release an AI clone unless a developer pays, a matter for law enforcement. It also reports that Valve would follow up on reported cases.

Valve does set one rule for every game. Its Content Survey page says that under the Steam Distribution Agreement, you promise your game will not include illegal or infringing content. Valve checks AI generated content against that promise in its prerelease review, the same way as other content.

Sources: Game Developer (28 October 2026); heise online (29 October 2026); Steamworks Content Survey documentation.

## Which games are easiest to clone?

Games built on one gimmick, with neutral art, inside a known genre. Chris Zukowski of How To Market A Game lists four signs. He stresses that these are not reasons to stop making a game. They are reasons to have a demo ready before you start to market it.

He separates a gimmick from a hook. A gimmick is one clever mechanic that players understand at once, like a joke. A hook only shows its full value after hours of play with several systems.

*Four signs that a game is easier to clone, from How To Market A Game (November 2026)*

| Sign | Why it helps a cloner | Lower risk |
| --- | --- | --- |
| A gimmick sells the game | One mechanic is quick to rebuild | A deep hook that needs hours to see |
| Art is not a feature | Neutral, realistic art is easy to match | A bold, distinct visual style |
| Well known genre design | Known parts are easy to mix again | Unexpected design inside the genre |
| Simple systemic content | Numbers and a clear end state copy fast | Deep simulation or hand made content |

Sources: How To Market A Game (11 November 2026).

## How do I report a clone on Steam?

Use the copyright form for copied assets, and the trademark form for your registered name. The Steamworks Content Survey FAQ sends copyright holders to the DMCA notice form and trademark owners to the Trademark Complaint Form.

The copyright form warns that a claim is a serious legal matter. It suggests you contact the person first, because it may be a misunderstanding. It also says your name and email may go to the person you report, and that knowingly false claims can bring damages under Section 512(f) of the DMCA. The trademark form asks for your trademark numbers and the countries where they are filed.

1. Save the store page of the copy: capsule, screenshots, trailer, text and developer name, with the date.
2. List each copied item next to your original, with dates that show yours came first.
3. For copied art, sound, text or code, file the Notice of Copyright Infringement form as the owner.
4. For a copied registered name or logo, file the Trademark Complaint Form with your registration numbers.
5. Add a note to your original page, as Valve suggests, that says who owns it.
6. Keep a copy of what you sent and report any new page of the same copy again.

Sources: Steamworks Content Survey documentation; Steam Notice of Copyright Infringement form; Steam Trademark Complaint Form.

## Should I register a trademark for my game?

Yes, if the name matters to you and you can pay the fee. The USPTO says you own a trademark as soon as you use it, but those rights are limited to the area where you sell. Registration gives nationwide rights in the United States. The base fee is $350 for each class of goods or services.

In the EU, the EUIPO charges a basic online fee of €850 for one class, €50 for the second class and €150 for each class from the third. An EU trade mark is valid for 10 years and can be renewed.

A trademark covers the name only for the goods or services you list. It does not stop a clone of your mechanic. It does give you the numbers that the Steam trademark form asks for.

*Trademark filing fees and terms from the USPTO and EUIPO pages*

| Office | Fee | Scope |
| --- | --- | --- |
| USPTO (United States) | $350 base fee per class | Nationwide rights after registration |
| EUIPO (European Union) | €850 for 1 class, €50 for the 2nd, €150 each from the 3rd | All EU countries, 10 years, renewable |

Sources: USPTO What is a trademark; USPTO How much does it cost; EUIPO Fees and payments.

## Should I hide my game or skip the demo?

Usually not. Zukowski argues that the first quality demo wins, and that hiding costs more than a clone. In the haystack case, the original game still gained 60 to 70 followers a day without a demo, which he estimates at about 600 or more wishlists a day. It also signed with a publisher.

His advice for games with the four signs is to stay quiet until a demo is ready, then release it fast if clones appear. For other games, he says the plan has not changed: a Steam page at least 6 months before launch, a demo, Steam Next Fest and as many wishlists as possible.

Watch for early signals. New pages with names close to yours, a demo of a copy that reaches creators first, and a sudden drop in your daily wishlist rate all say it is time to act.

- [Do Steam demos increase sales?](https://manalens.dev/blog/do-steam-demos-increase-sales)
- [itch.io for playtesting: restricted pages and keys](https://manalens.dev/blog/itch-io-playtesting)

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 October 2026); How To Market A Game (11 November 2026).

## How do I see if a clone hurts my wishlists?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. With a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access), it syncs your wishlist adds, deletes, purchases and gifts per day and country. You see at once if a copy changes your daily rate, and tracked short links show which creators still send players to your page.

- [Wishlist velocity calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/wishlist-velocity-calculator)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### Can I copyright my game mechanic?

No. The U.S. Copyright Office says copyright does not protect the idea for a game, its name or title, or the methods for playing it. It can protect the art, rules text, music and code. So a game with the same mechanic and new assets is usually not a copyright case.

### Will Valve remove a clone of my game?

Valve acts on copyright and trademark claims through its two forms, not on similar gameplay. File the copyright form for copied art, sound, text or code. File the trademark form for a registered name or logo. Valve said in October 2026 that it would follow up on reported extortion cases.

### Should I pay someone who threatens to clone my game?

No. heise online reports that Valve staff called these threats a matter for law enforcement, and that one developer got a demand for $200. Keep the email and report it. Then keep your demo plan ready, in case a real copy of your game appears on Steam.

### Does a trademark stop clones?

Only clones that use your name or logo. A trademark covers the name for the goods you list, and the USPTO says it does not give rights to the word in general. It gives you registration numbers for the Steam trademark form. It does not cover mechanics, which no law here protects.

## Sources

- [U.S. Copyright Office: Games (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.copyright.gov/register/tx-games.html)
- [U.S. Copyright Office: Circular 33, Works Not Protected by Copyright (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ33.pdf)
- [Steamworks documentation: Content Survey (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/gettingstarted/contentsurvey)
- [Steam Community: Notice of Copyright Infringement form (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://steamcommunity.com/dmca/create/)
- [Steam Community: Trademark Complaint Form (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://steamcommunity.com/trademark/createtrademarkcomplaint/)
- [USPTO: What is a trademark? (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/what-trademark)
- [USPTO: How much does it cost? (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/how-much-does-it-cost)
- [EUIPO: Fees and payments (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.euipo.europa.eu/en/trade-marks/before-applying/fees-payments)
- [Game Developer: Valve weighs in on Next Fest AI cloning phenomenon (Imran Khan, 28 October 2026)](https://www.gamedeveloper.com/pc/valve-addresses-steam-ai-cloning-problem)
- [heise online: Valve on AI Clones: Community and Updates Can Protect Indie Games (Daniel Herbig, 29 October 2026)](https://www.heise.de/en/news/Valve-on-AI-Clones-Community-and-Updates-Can-Protect-Indie-Games-11504134.html)
- [Game Developer: Moonlighter developer delays public playtest of next game over concerns of AI cloning (Bryant Francis, 19 October 2026)](https://www.gamedeveloper.com/programming/moonlighter-developer-delays-public-playtest-of-next-game-over-concerns-of-ai-cloning)
- [Kotaku: Devs of Needle In A Haystack clone angry it's been cloned by AI (Lewis Parker, 18 October 2026)](https://kotaku.com/devs-behind-needle-in-a-haystack-clone-complain-their-clone-has-been-cloned-by-vibe-coder-2000747284)
- [GamesRadar+: Dev who copied a popular game on Steam complains another copycat "stole our code" (Austin Wood, 29 October 2026)](https://www.gamesradar.com/games/dev-who-copied-a-popular-game-on-steam-complains-another-copycat-stole-our-code-and-now-its-apparently-been-kicked-out-by-valve/)
- [How To Market A Game: AI Cloners Are Here. Are Indie Devs Cooked? (Chris Zukowski, 28 October 2026)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2026/10/28/ai-cloners-are-here-are-indie-devs-cooked/)
- [How To Market A Game: How Clone-Proof Is Your Game? 4 Signs to Check (Chris Zukowski, 11 November 2026)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2026/11/11/how-clone-proof-is-your-game-4-signs-to-check/)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [Do Steam demos increase sales?](https://manalens.dev/blog/do-steam-demos-increase-sales)
- [Steam AI disclosure](https://manalens.dev/blog/steam-ai-disclosure)
- [How to name your game](https://manalens.dev/blog/how-to-name-your-game)
- [Wishlist velocity calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/wishlist-velocity-calculator)
- [Demo conversion calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/demo-conversion-calculator)
- [Steam and itch.io publishing guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/game-publishing)
- [Steam Community Hub guide: discussions, moderation, guides and announcements](https://manalens.dev/blog/steam-community-hub-guide)
- [The first year after a Steam launch: a month by month plan](https://manalens.dev/blog/first-year-after-steam-launch)
- [How long does Steam review take?](https://manalens.dev/blog/how-long-does-steam-review-take)
- [Steam release date: Coming soon vs To be announced](https://manalens.dev/blog/steam-release-date-coming-soon-vs-to-be-announced)
