What is a comp?
A comp is a comparable game: a recent game in the same genre and at the same scale as yours. Chris Zukowski of How To Market A Game says to use games released in the last 3 years. Do not use only the biggest hits. Also look at the failures and at the hidden gems that sell well.
Comps answer two questions. What do games like this sell? What do they charge? A publisher asks both, and you should ask them before you spend years on a game.
Sources: How To Market A Game (23 August 2022).
How do I find comps?
Start from Steam and SteamDB. Zukowski suggests three places: the "More Like This" list on a similar Steam page (click "View All"), the tag view on SteamDB for your main genre with recent releases, and Steam's interactive recommender.
He suggests about 10 games. After that you should have a good sense of what comparable games sell for.
- Open the Steam page of the game closest to yours and click "View All" under "More Like This".
- Open the SteamDB tag page for your main genre and sort by release date.
- Keep only games from the last 3 years at a scope like yours.
- Add at least one game that sold poorly.
- Stop at about 10 games.
Sources: How To Market A Game (23 August 2022).
What should my comps sheet include?
One row for each game, with the facts you need to compare. Zukowski's columns are the game, its Steam link, the price, its quality compared with yours (better, worse or equal), and the community reception from its reviews.
Add the review count and the release date, so that you can estimate sales. Add the price history from SteamDB too. Zukowski suggests checking how often and how deeply each comp discounted, and how long it waited before its lowest price.
| Column | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Game and Steam link | Lets a reader check your work |
| Release date | Sets the sales per review that applies |
| Base price and price history | Shows how the comp discounted |
| Review count | Input for the sales estimate |
| Quality compared with yours | Better, worse or equal |
| Community reception | What players praise or complain about |
Sources: How To Market A Game (23 August 2022).
How do I estimate sales from Steam reviews?
Multiply the review count by a number of sales per review that fits the release year. In a 2020 GameDiscoverCo survey of 237 games, the median was 58 sales per review across all years. For games released in 2020 the median was 38, and the usual range was 20 to 60.
The number fell over time because Steam added a prompt that asks players to review, in October 2019. Games released before 2017 had a median of 74 sales per review.
Units are not money. GameDiscoverCo says that after discounts, Steam's cut, refunds and VAT, the developer gets roughly 30% to 50% of the "optimistic" gross number, or less with deep discounts.
| Launch year in the survey | Median sales per review |
|---|---|
| All years (237 games) | 58 |
| Before 2017 | 74 |
| 2019 | 51 |
| 2020 | 38 |
Sources: GameDiscoverCo (3 August 2020).
Which comps should I not use?
Old evergreen hits and a list made only of hits. GameDiscoverCo uses Dead Cells as the example: it came out in 2018, when the genre had fewer games, and it had years of DLC and free updates. Use such a game only as one high-end comp.
GameDiscoverCo also says a deck with three comps that each sold over 1 million units is unrealistic. Two big comps and a 50,000-seller is believable.
Sources: GameDiscoverCo (3 August 2022).
How do I present comps in a pitch?
Show a range and say how you estimated it. GameDiscoverCo notes that a developer who pitches a publisher can lean optimistic, because the publisher will build its own view. A developer who spends its own money needs a more careful view and a plan B.
Our worked example, not data from a source: a comp with 1,000 reviews from 2020 at 38 sales per review is about 38,000 units. At a $15 price, the gross is about $570,000. If you keep 30% to 50% of gross, that is about $171,000 to $285,000.
- One table with each comp, its release date, price, reviews and estimated units.
- A low, middle and high case, with the low case based on your weakest comp.
- One line on why each comp did well or badly.
- What you will do differently from the comp that failed.
Sources: GameDiscoverCo (3 August 2022); GameDiscoverCo (3 August 2020).
What do comps tell me about price?
How often your genre discounts, and how deep. Zukowski says that on Steam, nobody buys games at full price, because Steam is built around discounts. A discount of 20% or more emails wishlisters, and featuring such as a Daily Deal needs a deep discount.
So open the SteamDB price history for each comp. Note how often it was discounted, by how much, and how long it waited before its lowest price. If a comp was in Early Access, compare its Early Access price with its 1.0 price.
His rule of thumb: add 20% to 30% to your price, because you will mostly sell on discount. He also suggests charging about 20% more than the comps you rate as equal to yours.
Sources: How To Market A Game (23 August 2022).
How do I turn comps into a budget check?
Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Once the game is live, the automatic Steam sync (in early access) records units and net sales per day, so you can compare your real numbers with your comps. Before that, use the sales estimator to turn review counts into a low, middle and high range.
Sources: Manalens product documentation.
Frequently asked questions
How many comps do I need?
About 10 for your own research, as Chris Zukowski suggests. Choose games from the last 3 years in your genre and at your scale, and include at least one that sold poorly. For a pitch deck, show a smaller set with a low, middle and high case, and say how you estimated each one.
How many copies does a Steam game sell per review?
GameDiscoverCo surveyed 237 games in 2020. The median was 58 sales per review across all years, 51 for 2019 games and 38 for 2020 games, with a usual range of 20 to 60 for new games. Use a number that fits the release year of each comp.
Can I use a big hit as a comp?
Use it as one high-end comp at most. GameDiscoverCo says a deck with three comps that each sold over 1 million units looks unrealistic. Old hits also launched into less crowded genres and had years of updates, so their lifetime sales overstate what a new game can expect.
How much of the gross revenue does a developer keep?
GameDiscoverCo says that after the average sale price, discounts, the Steam cut, refunds and VAT, the developer gets roughly 30% to 50% of the optimistic gross number, and less if it discounts deeply. So multiply estimated units by price, then apply that range.