# Email list to wishlists: how to measure your game newsletter

> How to tag every newsletter link, read wishlists per issue in Steamworks, measure the send-day lift, and why open rates are no longer a good measure.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-19. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/game-newsletter-to-wishlists

A newsletter can bring wishlists that last. In one Failbetter Games email, How To Market A Game reported a 26% open rate, a 2% click rate, a 0.6% unsubscribe rate and 1,200 wishlists so far (June 2022). Measure each issue by tagged Steam clicks, UTM wishlists and the wishlist lift on the send day.

## Key points

- A single Failbetter Games newsletter brought 1,200 wishlists so far, with a 2% click rate and 0.6% of readers unsubscribing.
- Judge each newsletter issue by tagged clicks and wishlists, not opens, because Apple Mail Privacy Protection fires tracking pixels for unread emails.
- Give each newsletter issue its own utm_content, then import the Steam UTM CSV after 4 days, when Steam finalizes conversions.

## What does a game newsletter bring?

Wishlists and sales from your most loyal fans, over a long tail. Failbetter Games sent one email to a list of hundreds of thousands of people who had played Fallen London. Zukowski reported the results and noted that email typically has a very long tail compared with most social media.

Tiny Glade shows a list built before a Steam page. Zukowski says the team posted prototypes, pointed people to a mailing list, and built it up to 25,000 subscribers. He calls newsletters the best converting way to keep in contact with fans.

| Metric | Failbetter result | Range Zukowski gives |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Open rate | 26% | 15% to 30% for a good list |
| Click rate | 2% | 1% to 15% |
| Unsubscribe rate | 0.6% | Spam flags start around 3% |
| Wishlists | 1,200 so far | Not given |

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 June 2022; 10 March 2025); Game Developer Podcast with Chris Zukowski (1 September 2023).

## Should my main call to action be the newsletter or the wishlist?

The wishlist, once your Steam page is live. Zukowski says more people are willing to wishlist a game than join a mailing list. He recommends pushing the wishlist first, then reminding people to join the list.

Before the Steam page exists, the newsletter is the call to action. Then, on the day the page goes live, you send the list a link so they can wishlist it. He suggests Substack as a free option that lets you keep the email addresses.

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 June 2022; 10 March 2025).

## How do I tag newsletter links?

Use utm_medium=email on every link and one campaign per issue. Most email tools can add UTMs for you. Kit adds utm_source=kit, utm_medium=email and a campaign from the subject and ID. Buttondown adds the newsletter username, the email slug, the email ID and medium email. beehiiv adds your publication, email or referral, and the post title.

All three keep UTMs that you add by hand. That matters for Steam links. Steam hides UTM combinations with little traffic, so set utm_source and utm_campaign yourself on Steam links, and keep the values few and stable.

``` A Steam link in a newsletter issue (480 is an example app ID)
https://store.steampowered.com/app/480/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=page_live&utm_content=issue_12
```

Sources: Kit Help Center; Buttondown documentation; beehiiv Help; Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

## Why should I not judge an issue by its open rate?

Because opens are no longer counted well. Apple Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background by default, whether or not the reader opens the email. The tracking pixel then fires for people who never read it.

Zukowski also warns that plain text options in some tools remove the tracking pixel, so those opens are not seen at all. Use clicks on tagged links, wishlists per issue and the send-day lift instead. Keep the open rate only as a rough trend.

Sources: Apple, Mail Privacy Protection; How To Market A Game (29 November 2017).

## How do I measure wishlists per issue?

Read the issue in the Steam UTM report, then check the lift. Steam credits a wishlist only when a signed-in player adds the game within 72 hours of the click. Many readers open email on a phone and wishlist later in the Steam client, so the UTM count is a floor.

1. Give each issue its own utm_content, and each major send, such as the page launch, its own utm_campaign.
2. Note the daily wishlist adds for the 7 days before the send. This is the baseline.
3. Send the issue with one clear call to action, as Zukowski advises.
4. After 4 days, when Steam finalizes conversions, import the UTM CSV and read wishlists for that utm_content.
5. Sum the wishlist adds for the send day and the next two days, and subtract the baseline for the same days. This is the lift.
6. Write both numbers in your issue log, next to clicks and unsubscribes.

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics and Wishlists documentation; Manalens Steam documentation.

## What should the launch-day email contain?

One action and one link. Zukowski advises single-subject emails with one action, because an email with many sections leaves readers unsure what to do. On launch day, that action is to buy, or to wishlist if the page just went live.

Steam also emails your wishlisters. Valve sends an email at launch and for discounts of 20% or more that last over 8 hours. Your own email lands on the same day, so the lift on launch day mixes both. Keep your newsletter link tagged so the UTM rows still show your share.

Sources: How To Market A Game (29 November 2017); Steamworks Wishlists documentation.

## How do I grow the list?

Give people a reason to join. Zukowski says very few people sign up for news and updates, and a small freebie greatly increases signups. His ideas include the soundtrack, a concept art book, a short story, a hint guide or beta access.

Add a signup in the game too. He notes that few players visit your website, so an in-game form, with an unlockable item for subscribers, reaches more of them. Tag the link to the form from each channel, so you know which channel brings subscribers.

Sources: How To Market A Game (29 November 2017; 28 June 2022).

## How often should I send?

Often enough that readers remember you. Zukowski cites the common advice to email your list at least once every two weeks. He also suggests a ratio of three emails that give something of value for every one email that asks readers to buy, which he calls give, give, give, ask.

For measurement, a steady rhythm helps. When issues go out on the same weekday, the baseline for each send day is easier to read, and an issue with a weak result stands out. Log the date, the call to action, the clicks, the UTM wishlists and the lift for every issue in one sheet.

- [Game community health metrics: how to measure your Discord, Steam hub and subreddit](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-community-health-metrics)

Sources: How To Market A Game (29 November 2017).

## Where do newsletter visits show in Manalens?

In the Email channel. The collector puts a visit in Email when utm_medium is email, e-mail, e_mail or newsletter, or when the referrer is a webmail site or a newsletter host such as Substack, beehiiv or Paragraph. Links in the email that go to your own site then show by issue in the UTM breakdowns.

For conversions, use the Attribution page or Ask AI with a conversion event, such as game_open or a signup event, and group by campaign. The product does not compute the lift; you subtract the baseline yourself.

Sources: Manalens attribution documentation.

## How do I measure each issue?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Tag every issue, import the Steam UTM report and sync daily wishlist adds with a Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access). Then clicks, UTM wishlists and the daily count for the send day sit side by side.

- [UTM builder](https://manalens.dev/tools/utm-builder)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a good open rate for a game newsletter?

Zukowski calls 15% to 30% a good open rate, and Failbetter reached 26%. But Apple Mail Privacy Protection loads images in the background, so many opens are not real reads. Judge issues by clicks on tagged links, UTM wishlists and the wishlist lift on the send day.

### Which UTM values should I use for newsletter links?

Use utm_source=newsletter, utm_medium=email, one utm_campaign per major send and the issue in utm_content. Kit, Buttondown and beehiiv can add UTMs for you and keep values you set by hand. On Steam links, set the values yourself so they stay few and stable.

### Will emailing my list too often cost me subscribers?

Less than most indies fear. In the Failbetter email, 0.6% of readers unsubscribed, and Zukowski says email services start to flag spam at around 3%. Watch the unsubscribe rate per issue, and send one clear action per email rather than long updates.

### Should I use Substack or a paid email tool?

Either works if you keep the email addresses. Zukowski suggests Substack as a free option for that reason. Tools such as Kit, Buttondown or beehiiv can add UTMs to every link for you. What matters more is one call to action per email and tagged links.

## Sources

- [How To Market A Game: Using mailing lists to gain thousands of wishlists (Chris Zukowski, 28 June 2022)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2022/06/28/using-mailing-lists-to-gain-thousands-of-wishlists/)
- [How To Market A Game: When should I post my Steam coming-soon page? (Chris Zukowski, 10 March 2025)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2025/03/10/when-should-i-post-my-steam-coming-soon-page/)
- [How To Market A Game: Email Marketing 101 (Chris Zukowski, 29 November 2017)](https://howtomarketagame.com/2017/11/29/email-marketing-101-how-to-actually-use-your-mailing-list/)
- [Game Developer Podcast: indie marketing advice with Chris Zukowski (1 September 2023)](https://www.gamedeveloper.com/marketing/game-developer-podcast-36-indie-marketing-advice-from-chris-zukowski)
- [Kit Help Center: Automatic UTM parameters (read 18 November 2026)](https://help.kit.com/en/articles/4446616-automatic-utm-parameters)
- [Buttondown documentation: UTM parameters (read 18 November 2026)](https://docs.buttondown.com/utm)
- [beehiiv Help: UTM parameter tracking (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.beehiiv.com/support/article/14492992521367)
- [Apple: Mail Privacy Protection and privacy (read 18 November 2026)](https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/mail-privacy-protection/)
- [Steamworks documentation: UTM Analytics (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/utm_analytics)
- [Steamworks documentation: Wishlists (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/marketing/wishlist)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [Attribute Discord, newsletter and Bluesky links to wishlists](https://manalens.dev/blog/attribute-community-channels-to-wishlists)
- [Do you need a website for your indie game?](https://manalens.dev/blog/indie-game-website)
- [Incrementality for game marketing on a small budget](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-incrementality)
- [UTM builder](https://manalens.dev/tools/utm-builder)
- [Wishlist velocity calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/wishlist-velocity-calculator)
- [Immutable Audience alternatives for Steam wishlist growth](https://manalens.dev/compare/immutable-audience-alternatives)
- [Game marketing guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/game-marketing)
- [Marketing mix modelling vs attribution for indie studios](https://manalens.dev/blog/marketing-mix-modelling-vs-attribution-games)
- [Devlogs: do they sell games? What the numbers show](https://manalens.dev/blog/do-devlogs-sell-games)
- [Web analytics for game studios: your website, Steam links and web builds](https://manalens.dev/blog/web-analytics-for-game-studios)
- [Indie game branding for your first game](https://manalens.dev/blog/indie-game-branding)
