What is cross promotion between indie games?

Cross promotion is when two or more developers promote each other's games to their own audiences. It costs no ad money. It costs time, trust and a small share of your audience's attention.

In a 2021 GDC talk, Philomena Schwab of Stray Fawn Studio said 65% of developers had done some form of cross promotion more than once. She named four basic types: shout-outs, knowledge sharing, themed sales and tool sharing. Her own shout-out example was a Reddit post about a friend's game, Omno, that got 80K upvotes.

The risk is that a swap feels fair but is not. One partner can send many visits and get few back. Tagged links show this.

Sources: How To Market A Game GDC 2021 wrap-up (Philomena Schwab talk).

Which Steam tools can you use to cross promote?

Steam gives you five main places: your developer homepage, franchise pages, collaborative bundles, links in your own store page and events, and themed sales. Each one has different rules and a different cost in effort.

Valve says players can follow a developer or publisher homepage, and followers get an email when a linked game launches, enters Early Access or leaves Early Access. You can also make lists on the homepage, for example a list of games in a current promotion. A franchise page is only for games that share a creative universe or IP, so it does not fit games from different studios.

In her GDC talk, Schwab said a link to another Steam game in the special announcements section of a store page turns into a widget. She estimated that one third of her studio's wishlists came from that widget. That is one studio's estimate, not a benchmark.

Steam cross promotion options and what each one needs
OptionWho can joinWhat to measure
Developer homepage listYour own gamesHomepage followers; visits to each game
Franchise pageGames in the same creative universeFranchise followers; launch emails
Collaborative bundleAny developers who agreeBundle units in the sales CSV
Store page or event links to a partnerAny Steam gameVisits and wishlists per tagged link
Themed sale or festivalA group with a sale pageVisits through the tagged sale page

Sources: Steamworks Developer and Publisher Homepages documentation; Steamworks collaborative bundles documentation; How To Market A Game GDC 2021 wrap-up (Philomena Schwab talk).

How do collaborative bundles work on Steam?

A collaborative bundle holds games from different developers, and each developer approves every change. Valve suggests the Complete the Set type, so you can add games over time.

Valve pays each partner for its own package. A bundle sale shows up as one unit of each game in the bundle, and the Sales and Activations CSV marks package sales that came from a bundle. No revenue split is possible.

Valve also warns that only the bundle owner can change the description, localization, store visibility and artwork, and those changes need no approval. Pick partners you trust. Steam sends no email when a bundle needs your approval, so agree on a way to talk.

  1. The owner creates a bundle and turns on collaborative mode.
  2. The owner shares the secret URL with each partner.
  3. Each partner adds its package; this needs the Manage Pricing and Discounts permission.
  4. The owner locks the bundle, and every partner approves the final state.
  5. Any new game or new discount needs every partner to approve again.

Sources: Steamworks collaborative bundles documentation; Steamworks Bundles documentation.

How do you measure a newsletter swap?

Give each partner newsletter its own short link, then read clicks and Steam wishlists for that link. A newsletter link opens in an email app or browser, often away from the Steam client, so clicks are the first number to check.

Read three numbers per partner: clicks on the short link, tracked Steam visits for its UTM values, and wishlists from those visits. Then check total daily wishlists for the two days after the send. Steam UTM data covers only signed-in visitors in the same browser, so the daily total catches some of the rest.

For more on your own list, see our newsletter guide.

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Manalens product documentation (short links).

What results have developers measured?

Results are real but uneven between partners. In the 2023 Strategy Fest swap, the 17 games gained 1,108 visits and 115 wishlists in total. Our arithmetic: that is about 10 wishlists per 100 visits.

One game, Elaborate Lands, provided 330 visits and 33 wishlists to its group. Mystical Conquests gained the most visits in its group, with 117. Many partners kept the links up after the fest and saw a steady trickle of visits and wishlists.

An older case is the 2010 Organic Indie Preorder Pack from Wolfire Games and Unknown Worlds. Wolfire had 1,100 preorders of Overgrowth in the year before. In one week, the two studios sold 1,658 packs. Regular preorders of both games also went up during the promotion.

Measured cross promotion results from developer post-mortems
PromotionYearMeasured result
Strategy Fest swap, 17 games20231,108 visits and 115 wishlists in total
Strategy Fest, 4X group top provider2023Elaborate Lands provided 330 visits and 33 wishlists
Strategy Fest, RPG and tactical group top gainer2023Superstar Strategy gained 91 visits and 17 wishlists
Organic Indie Preorder Pack20101,658 packs in one week, against 1,100 preorders in the year before

Sources: Medium, Curious Dynamics (25 September 2023); Wolfire Games Blog, Jeffrey Rosen (25 January 2010).

How do you judge each partner fairly?

Compare what each partner gave with what it got, in visits and in wishlists. A big game sends more traffic than it gets. That is normal, and the Strategy Fest group saw it: games with streamer attention during the fest sent more clicks to the group.

Use the wishlist rate per partner too. The best rate in the 4X group was 42% (DR4X), and in the RPG and tactical group it was 28% (dotAGE). A high rate shows audience fit, even on few visits. Use the fit data to pick bundle partners next time.

  • Visits sent and received per partner.
  • Wishlists sent and received per partner.
  • Wishlists per 100 tracked visits for each partner link.
  • Whether the link still brings visits a month later.

Sources: Medium, Curious Dynamics (25 September 2023).

How do I see what each partner sent?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Create one short link per partner with the Channel field set, import the Steam UTM report, and group Steam rows by source or content in Explorer. Then compare clicks, tracked visits and wishlists for every partner in one place. Build the Steam links with the UTM builder.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make a Steam bundle with another developer's game?

Yes. Valve calls it a collaborative bundle. The owner turns on collaborative mode and shares a secret URL. Each partner adds its own package and approves the final bundle. Valve pays each partner for its own package, and every new game or discount change needs all partners to approve again.

Do UTM links work between two Steam pages?

The Strategy Fest group used UTM terms on links from one Steam page to another and read visits and wishlists in Steamworks. Valve counts links to app pages or sale pages that have utm_source or utm_campaign. A wishlist counts if a signed-in user adds it within 72 hours of the click.

How many games should be in a cross promotion group?

There is no rule from Valve. The 2023 Strategy Fest swap split 17 games into two groups by sub-genre, of 8 and 9 games. Philomena Schwab suggested 3 to 7 games for a bundle, so the price does not get too high. Match games by genre so the audiences overlap.

What is a good result for a cross promotion swap?

There is no public benchmark. The 2023 Strategy Fest swap brought 1,108 visits and 115 wishlists across 17 games, which is small per game. The value is in the low cost and in links that keep working. Judge it by wishlists per partner and by how long the trickle lasts.

Sources and implementation