Does itch.io success predict Steam success?

It is a signal, not a promise. Chris Zukowski called itch.io success a necessary but not sufficient condition for doing well on Steam. In his case studies, many itch.io hits also did well on Steam, some did only average, and none that did poorly on itch.io did well on Steam.

The table shows the games in the post. Steam reviews and peak players are public numbers that stand in for sales.

itch.io views compared with Steam results.
Gameitch.io viewsSteam result in the post
Die in the Dungeon1,409,0641,694 reviews, peak 2,848 players
NIMRODS123,0001,203 reviews, peak 2,168 players
Mushroom Musume458,208986 followers
Killer Chat!645,0001,073 followers
Tiny Kingdom198,000107 reviews, peak 103 players

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025).

Why did some itch.io hits do poorly on Steam?

Free players are not the same as buyers, and the full game must be more than the prototype. For Tiny Kingdom, the author points to poor balance at launch, a cozy marketing angle for a strategic game, email outreach only four days before release, and a prototype that looked too much like the full game.

Tiny Kingdom still reached more than 10K wishlists in 6 months, and its itch.io homepage feature added about 250 wishlists.

The lesson is to test the full game with the people you want to sell to, not only with free players. Watch retention and comments in playtests of the paid version before launch.

Free players forgive rough edges that buyers will not.

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025).

What does a successful move look like?

The Roottrees are Dead is the clearest public case. It was made in 48 hours at Global Game Jam in January 2023 and released free on itch.io in November 2023. The tip jar earned $3,000 in the first month. A rebuilt version launched on Steam on 15 January 2025 at $19.99 with over 13,000 wishlists. It passed 1,000 reviews within 3 weeks and earned over $1 million.

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 April 2025).

Which itch.io signals should I watch?

Look for a mix of signals, not one number. The author advises the same. Views alone can come from one feature.

  • Lifetime views above 10,000, the tier where featuring and streamer coverage appear.
  • Plays per view above the 37% median for browser games.
  • Streamers who found the game without being asked.
  • Players who return: D1 and D7 retention from an SDK in the build.
  • Comments that ask for more content, or tips on a free game.

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025); How To Market A Game (12 May 2025).

How do I move players from itch.io to Steam?

Keep the itch.io version up and point it at the Steam page. The author suggests keeping the itch.io version under a classic label and making a large visual and content upgrade for Steam. During the NIMRODS Steam launch, its itch.io demo peaked at 2,000 views and 1,300 plays.

  1. Open the Steam page while the itch.io game still gets traffic.
  2. Add a Steam wishlist link to the itch.io page and to the end screen of the build, with utm_source=itch.
  3. Post a devlog on itch.io for each Steam milestone.
  4. Read the Steamworks UTM report each week to count wishlists from itch.io.
  5. Keep the itch.io build live under a classic label after the Steam launch.

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

When should I open the Steam page?

While the itch.io game still gets traffic. The Roottrees are Dead had about 8,000 Steam wishlists before its final push and over 13,000 at launch, about 14 months after the free itch.io release. Tiny Kingdom reached more than 10K wishlists in 6 months.

A page that opens late misses the players who arrive during the itch.io peak, because they have nowhere to wishlist the game.

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 April 2025); How To Market A Game (22 May 2025).

Should I use itch.io instead of Steam Early Access?

For feedback, the author of the case studies suggests itch.io. He recommends itch.io, not Steam Early Access, as the place to get player feedback before the Steam release.

If you do, give each itch.io build a version name in your SDK. Then you can read retention for each build and see which change helped.

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025); Manalens app events documentation.

What should change between the itch.io and the Steam version?

Enough that players see a new game. The author recommends a large visual and content upgrade. The Roottrees are Dead was rebuilt for Steam by a new developer after the jam version.

  • Visuals that look clearly better in screenshots and the trailer.
  • More content: levels, modes or story.
  • Balance that you tested with players before launch.
  • A marketing angle that matches how the game really plays.

Sources: How To Market A Game (22 May 2025); How To Market A Game (28 April 2025).

How do I keep players across both builds?

Use one analytics project for both builds and set the storefront in each. The itch.io build sends storefront itch and the Steam build sends storefront steam, so you can filter and compare them. If players create an account, send an identify event from your server; then a player who moves from the free build to the Steam build stays one profile.

Sources: Manalens app events and web SDK documentation.

How long did the move take for The Roottrees are Dead?

About two years from jam to Steam, and 14 months from the free itch.io release. The table shows the timeline that How To Market A Game published.

DateStep
January 2023Made in 48 hours at Global Game Jam
February 2023Polish, playtests and changes begin
March 2023Sean Plott (Day[9]) plays the prototype
November 2023Free release on itch.io
December 2023Robin Ward starts to rebuild the game for Steam
15 January 2025Steam launch at $19.99

Sources: How To Market A Game (28 April 2025).

How do I measure the move from itch.io to Steam?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Tag the Steam link in your itch.io page and build, import the Steam UTM report, and keep the SDK in both builds. Then compare itch.io players, Steam wishlists from itch.io, and retention in one project.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Should I take my free itch.io game down before the Steam launch?

How To Market A Game suggests you keep it up under a classic label. The free version keeps bringing players who can wishlist the Steam game. Make the Steam version a clear upgrade in visuals and content, so players see why it costs money.

How many itch.io views do I need before Steam?

There is no fixed number. In the 2025 benchmark, games above 10,000 lifetime views were the ones with featuring and streamer coverage. Tiny Kingdom had 198,000 views and still did poorly on Steam, so check retention and player comments too.

Can itch.io players wishlist my game?

Yes, if you give them a link. Add a Steam link with utm_source=itch to the itch.io page and the end screen of the build. The Steamworks UTM report then counts wishlists from tracked visits within 72 hours of the click.

Does an itch.io feature bring Steam wishlists?

Some. How To Market A Game reports that the itch.io homepage feature for Tiny Kingdom added about 250 Steam wishlists. To measure it for your game, put a tagged Steam link on the itch.io page and read the Steamworks UTM report during the feature.

Sources and implementation