# UGC and mods: effect on game sales and retention

> What published data says about mod support, sales and player retention, why it is correlation and not proof, and how to measure mod users in your game.

By Yos Riady. Updated 2026-11-18. Published 2026-11-18. Canonical URL: https://manalens.dev/blog/ugc-mods-sales-retention

Official mod support goes with a longer game life. In GameDiscoverCo's 2025 study with mod.io of about 1,200 Steam games, games with UGC had 75% better concurrent players after 2 years and a 31% revenue advantage after 5 years. The study shows correlation, not cause, so measure mod users in your own game.

## Key points

- GameDiscoverCo's 2025 study of about 1,200 Steam games found a 31% revenue advantage after 5 years for games with official UGC.
- The mod study shows correlation, not cause, because engaged players and long-tail genres may explain why UGC games keep players longer.
- Send mod_enabled, mod_disabled and ugc_level_played events, then compare weekly cohorts from 4 weeks before and after mod support ships.

## Do mods increase game sales?

Games with official mod support sell more over time in the largest public study, but the study cannot prove that mods cause it. GameDiscoverCo ran the research with mod.io, a company that sells mod tools, in September 2025. It repeats an earlier study that found a 7% revenue advantage in year 1 and 23% after 5 years.

The Steam sample is about 1,200 games tracked for five years, all with more than $1 million in Steam revenue in their first month. Close to 20% of them have an official UGC solution. The console data covers games with more than 100,000 units sold or downloaded in month 1.

| Measure | Games with UGC vs games without | Platform |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Revenue, year 1 | 8% advantage | Steam |
| Revenue, after 5 years | 31% advantage | Steam |
| Concurrent players, after 2 years | 75% better | Steam |
| Concurrent players, after 5 years | 115% difference | Steam |
| Total revenue per DLC | 105% bigger | Steam |
| Players, after 1 year | 16% advantage | PlayStation |
| Players, after 1 year | 24% advantage | Xbox |

Sources: GameDiscoverCo (26 September 2025).

## Do mods cause the gain?

Not proven. Simon Carless flags the correlation and causation problem himself: games that allow UGC can belong to genres that naturally have stronger long tails. A game that is popular enough to attract modders may also be a game that would have kept players anyway.

The two developer quotes in the study are anecdotes, not controlled tests. Saber says SnowRunner players who used mods were 2.4 times more likely to buy official DLC, which Carless calls possibly chicken and egg. Larian says Baldur's Gate 3 saw a 20% increase in daily active users across all platforms after official mod support in 2024.

The same bias appears in your own data. Players who install mods are often your most engaged players before they install anything. If you compare them with everyone else, mods will look better than they are.

Sources: GameDiscoverCo (26 September 2025).

## What does Steam Workshop give a developer?

Steam Workshop hosts community content for your game, in one of two forms. Your game still needs a way to upload items and to load what players download. A game appears in the Workshop front page list only when it has at least one published item.

Paid community content can be large for a big game. On 28 January 2015, Valve said payments to creators of items sold in Team Fortress 2, Dota 2 and Counter-Strike: Global Offensive had passed $57 million, spread across over 1,500 contributors in 75 countries. That is Valve's own games, not a typical indie result.

| Workshop type | How it works | Fits |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Ready-to-use | Anyone uploads, players download without review, authors update at any time | Many items, mods and maps |
| Curated | Players vote on submissions, and the developer accepts items | Tighter control, smaller items such as weapons or hats |

Sources: Steamworks Steam Workshop documentation; Steam News (28 January 2015).

## Which mod events should my game send?

Send one custom event when a player enables a mod or plays community content, with the mod ID and where it came from. Use flat snake_case names and properties. Property values can be strings, numbers, booleans or null, and they must not contain personal data.

Keep the list short. Three events cover most questions: mod_enabled, mod_disabled and ugc_level_played. Add a property such as source with values like workshop or manual, so you can split Steam Workshop users from players who install mods by hand.

``` Godot
Manalens.track("mod_enabled", {"mod_id": "better_maps", "source": "workshop"})
```

Sources: Manalens app events and Godot SDK documentation.

## How do I compare retention of mod users with other players?

Read a retention chart with and without a filter, then check the result against cohorts from before mod support. The filter shows how mod users behave. The before and after comparison is closer to the effect of mod support itself, because it compares whole cohorts and not self-selected players.

1. Open a dashboard, click Add chart and choose Retention with the Daily period.
2. Note D7 and D30 for all players.
3. Add the dashboard filter Event property mod_id is set. On a retention chart, dashboard filters keep only people with a matching event in the date range. Note D7 and D30 again and compare.
4. Note the day you shipped mod support. Compare the weekly cohorts from the 4 weeks before it with the 4 weeks after it.
5. Check that nothing else changed in those weeks, such as a sale, a large patch or a creator video. If it did, say so in your notes.

Sources: Manalens retention and filters documentation.

## Does mod support pay off for a small indie game?

There is no public data for small indie games. The GameDiscoverCo Steam sample starts at $1 million in first-month revenue, so it says little about a game that sells a few thousand copies. Mod support also costs time: tools, documentation, load order bugs and, for curated content, review work.

Look for signals before you build tools. Players who already edit config files, share levels on Discord or ask for a level editor show demand. A level editor inside the game can test that demand at a lower cost than a full Workshop integration.

Sources: GameDiscoverCo (26 September 2025); Steamworks Steam Workshop documentation.

## What should I check each month after mod support ships?

Check four numbers once a month and write them in one table, so you can see the trend and not a single spike.

- Mod adoption: players with a mod_enabled event, divided by MAU. A SQL chart can count the first; the Game KPIs dashboard shows the second.
- Retention of mod users and of all players, at D7 and D30, from the two retention charts.
- Active players: MAU and stickiness on the Game KPIs dashboard, to see whether the active base lasts longer than before.
- Crash-free sessions for players with mods. Mods often break after a game update, so click Edit chart on a Game health chart and add a condition on mod_enabled to its SQL query.

Sources: Manalens metrics, dashboards and game health documentation.

## How do I measure mods in my game?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Send mod_enabled from the Godot or Unity SDK, add a retention chart with an Event property filter, and compare cohorts before and after mod support. Then check your numbers with the retention calculator.

- [D1, D7, D30 retention calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/retention-calculator)

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

## Frequently asked questions

### Do Steam Workshop games keep players longer?

In GameDiscoverCo's 2025 study, Steam games with official UGC had 75% better concurrent players after 2 years and a 115% difference after 5 years. The sample is games with over $1 million in first-month revenue, and the author warns that this is correlation, not proof that mods cause it.

### Does free mod content hurt DLC sales?

The public data cannot say for sure. GameDiscoverCo found total revenue per DLC was 105% bigger for UGC games, but notes it cannot prove or disprove cannibalization. Saber reported SnowRunner mod users were 2.4 times more likely to buy DLC, which may only show that engaged players do both.

### Can I sell mods through Steam Workshop?

Yes, in some setups. In a ready-to-use Workshop with paid items, Steam handles payment processing, author payouts and tax withholding. In a curated Workshop, paid items need a persistent item service such as the Steam Inventory Service and an in-game store, and the developer sets the prices.

### Why do mod users look more loyal in my data?

Because many of them were already your most engaged players before they installed a mod. That is selection bias. To estimate the effect of mod support, compare whole weekly cohorts from before and after the release, and check that no sale, patch or creator video changed those weeks.

## Sources

- [GameDiscoverCo: Analysis, UGC (still) powers sales and retention (Simon Carless, 26 September 2025)](https://newsletter.gamediscover.co/p/analysis-ugc-still-powers-sales-and)
- [Steamworks documentation: Steam Workshop (Valve, read 18 November 2026)](https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/features/workshop)
- [Steam News: Content creators earn over $50M through Steam Workshop (Valve, 28 January 2015)](https://store.steampowered.com/news/15614)

## Related guides

- [Game marketing measurement guide](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-marketing-measurement-guide)
- [Cohort analysis for games](https://manalens.dev/blog/cohort-analysis-for-games)
- [Why players quit your game](https://manalens.dev/blog/why-players-quit-game-churn)
- [Game analytics dashboards: which charts matter](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-analytics-dashboard-charts)
- [D1, D7, D30 retention calculator](https://manalens.dev/tools/retention-calculator)
- [Game marketing guides](https://manalens.dev/blog/topic/game-marketing)
- [Game metrics every indie developer should track](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-metrics-indie-developers)
- [What events to track first in your game](https://manalens.dev/blog/game-tracking-plan-first-events)
- [D1, D7 and D30 retention benchmarks for PC and indie games](https://manalens.dev/blog/pc-indie-game-retention-benchmarks)
- [Measure the impact of updates and live ops on players](https://manalens.dev/blog/measure-game-update-impact)
