Why can an extra step cost wishlists?

Each step asks the visitor to make one more decision, and some visitors stop at each decision. A wishlist is one click for a player who is signed in to Steam. An email form needs typing, and sometimes a second confirmation step.

Chris Zukowski of How To Market A Game says this is why fewer people join a mailing list. He also says that if your main call to action is the mailing list, you turn away people who would have wishlisted but are not ready for that commitment.

Sources: How To Market A Game (Chris Zukowski, 28 June 2022).

Which ask should come first?

Ask for the wishlist first when you have a Steam page. Then ask for email or Discord as a second, optional step. Zukowski gives this order in his FAQ.

He describes the three asks as layers. Wishlists are for most people, Discord is for super fans, and the mailing list is for the most committed fans. Before your Coming Soon page is live, the mailing list is the main ask, because there is no wishlist button yet.

After the wishlist, ask again for the deeper step. Zukowski says to push people to wishlist, and then quickly and loudly remind them to join the mailing list. He adds that most subscribers join only after you offer something in return, such as beta access for an email address.

Which call to action to put first at each stage, from How To Market A Game advice
StageFirst askSecond ask
No Steam page yetMailing listNone
Coming Soon page liveSteam wishlistMailing list, for example a beta sign-up
Near launch, with a community managerSteam wishlistDiscord

Sources: How To Market A Game (Chris Zukowski, 14 March 2023); How To Market A Game (Chris Zukowski, 28 June 2022).

Where do visitors drop on a capture page?

Most of the loss happens at the move from your page to Steam. Valve can count a wishlist from your link only for a visitor who is signed in to Steam in that browser, or who opens the page in the Steam client or app from Valve's banner.

Valve says few players are signed in to Steam inside the built-in browsers of social apps. Some of them switch to the Steam app or the desktop client and search for the game, and Valve cannot connect those actions to your link.

Valve gives an example: 20 visits, of which 6 were signed in, and those 6 gave 2 wishlists and 1 purchase. So a click is not a wishlist, even with no form in the way.

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

What do the published cases show?

They show that many players skip your links and go to Steam on their own. Dan Pos of Slug Disco reported that a viral TikTok for the game Adapt had 429,000 views and brought 1,092 wishlists in one week. Only 17 people clicked the UTM link in the TikTok bio.

His reading is that most viewers were on a phone, not signed in to Steam, and searched for the game later on a computer. So a capture page in the bio would have seen only a small part of the interest.

Our arithmetic: 1,092 wishlists from 429,000 views is about 1 wishlist per 393 views, and 17 link clicks is about 1.6% of those wishlists.

Sources: Dan Pos, Slug Disco (YouTube).

How do I build a capture page that keeps wishlists?

Keep the Steam button as the main action, and make the email step optional. This list is our reasoning from the sources above. It is not a measured benchmark.

  1. Put one Steam wishlist button above the fold. Link it to your app page with utm_source or utm_campaign, so that Steam can record it.
  2. Put the email form below the button, or show it after the click. Ask for the email address only.
  3. Give a reason to join, for example a beta key or a demo date.
  4. Put the Discord invite last, and only when someone runs the server.
  5. Test the page on a phone. Check that the Steam button opens the store or the Steam app.

Sources: How To Market A Game (Chris Zukowski, 28 June 2022); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

How do I measure the cost of an extra step?

Measure each step as its own event, and compare two versions of the page on the same traffic. A single blended conversion rate hides the step where people leave.

Track three events on the page: the page view, the email submit and the Steam button click. Build a funnel from these steps and break it down by UTM source. Then compare the Steam UTM rows for each page version, by utm_content.

To split traffic, make two short links with the same campaign and a different utm_content, one for each version. Wait at least 4 days after the visits before you read Steam conversions, because Valve finalizes them then. Use a significance test before you call a winner.

A measurement plan for a wishlist capture page
StepWhat to recordWhere it shows
VisitPage view with UTMsYour web analytics
Email stepAn email_submitted custom eventYour funnel
Steam handoffA steam_click custom eventYour funnel
WishlistWishlists within 72 hours of a tagged clickSteam UTM Analytics

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Manalens product documentation.

Which articles cover the rest of the page?

This guide covers only the extra step. Our guide on landing page vs Steam page covers where to send traffic. Our visitor to wishlist guide covers how to connect a site visit with a later player.

Sources: Manalens guides.

How do I find the step where my page loses wishlists?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Track the page view, the email submit and the Steam click as events, and build a funnel of up to five steps with a breakdown by UTM source. Then upload the Steam UTM Analytics CSV to see wishlists for each page version. Use the conversion rate calculator to compare the steps.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Should my game website ask for email or a Steam wishlist?

Ask for the wishlist first when your Steam page is live, and offer email as a second step. Chris Zukowski says more people will wishlist a game than join a mailing list. Before you have a Coming Soon page, the mailing list is the main ask, because there is no wishlist button yet.

Does a Discord invite on my landing page hurt wishlists?

It can, if it competes with the Steam button as an equal choice. Put it after the wishlist ask. Chris Zukowski advises a Discord call to action near launch, and only when someone can manage the server, because a quiet server makes new members leave or mute it.

Why does Steam show fewer wishlists than my button clicks?

Steam counts a wishlist from your link only when the visitor is signed in to Steam in that browser, or opens the page in the Steam client or app, within 72 hours of the click. Valve says few players are signed in inside social app browsers. Many search for the game later instead.

Can I put a Steam button on my own site and still track it?

Yes. Valve says you can add UTM parameters to the address in the iframe code of a Steam store widget. Traffic through the widget and the conversions that follow can then appear in your UTM report. The visitor must still be signed in to Steam for Valve to count a wishlist.

How long should I wait before I compare two page versions?

Wait at least 4 days after the visits, because Valve finalizes UTM conversions 4 days after the visit. Run both versions over the same days and the same traffic source. Then compare wishlists per visit for each version, and check the result with a significance test before you decide.

Sources and implementation