Steam Playtest or demo?
A Steam Playtest is a free, separate test app for feedback that does not touch your reviews or wishlists. A demo is a free slice that sells the game, can send one wishlist notice and is required for Next Fest. Answer 7 yes or no questions to get a suggestion, with the reasons and the Valve rule behind each.
How to use it
- Answer each of the 7 questions with Yes or No.
- Read "Our suggestion": Playtest, Demo, Both or Not sure yet.
- Read the reasons under "Reasons for a demo" and "Reasons for a Playtest".
- Change any answer to see how the suggestion moves.
How it works
Each Yes adds points to a Playtest or a demo. Wanting to join Next Fest adds 3 points to the demo, because Next Fest needs a public demo. Wanting feedback on a build that still changes a lot adds 2 points to the Playtest. Every other Yes adds 1 point. If both reach 2 points, we suggest both. If neither has a point, the result is "Not sure yet". Otherwise we suggest the one with more points, and a tie goes to the demo. This is our own scoring.
Each reason restates a rule from Valve's Steam Playtest, Demos or Steam Next Fest pages, and the questions cover the main ways the two differ: who can play, reviews, wishlist notices, scale and Next Fest.
Playtest points = sum of the weights of Yes answers that point to a Playtest
demo points = sum of the weights of Yes answers that point to a demo
Both if Playtest points ≥ 2 and demo points ≥ 2
Not sure yet if both are 0, else the higher one, with a tie going to the demoWorked example
Example with made-up inputs: an online co-op survival game heading for Next Fest
The team answers Yes to Next Fest, to wanting feedback on a changing build, and to needing a large stress test. Demo points = 3. Playtest points = 2 + 1 = 3. Both reach 2, so the suggestion is "Both".
In practice that means order: run the Playtest first to stress test servers and fix bugs, then release the demo before the Next Fest deadline. With Yes to feedback and to controlling who plays, but No to Next Fest, the Playtest gets 2 + 1 = 3 points, the demo 0, and the suggestion is "Playtest".
How to read the result
"Both" usually means a sequence: a Playtest first to test the design and fix bugs with a group you control, then a polished demo. Chris Zukowski suggests this order, partly because a Playtest does not use up the one wishlist notice a demo release can send.
"Not sure yet" means none of your answers points to either. Put up the Coming Soon page and collect wishlists first, and come back when you have a build to share.
The suggestion is a starting point from our own scoring, not a Valve rule. Read the reasons, because one strong reason, such as Next Fest, can matter more than the points.
Playtest and demo side by side
A Playtest is a separate child app with no store page: players sign up in a section of your game's page, and you let them in by batches or open signups to all. You can also hand out Playtest keys before the store page is live. You cannot charge for it, and Playtest players cannot review the game. A demo is a separate app that can have its own store page with reviews, can appear anywhere a free game can on Steam, and can send one notice to your wishlisters.
Timing each one
Valve does not recommend a live Playtest during Next Fest, because it splits players between two builds. A demo can send its wishlist notice only once, within 14 days of first becoming playable, and Valve suggests spacing it at least two weeks from other wishlist notices, such as your release or a discount. Valve's demo page generally recommends waiting until launch, but says a demo before release helps when players need to play the game to understand it.
Limits
The suggestion comes from our own scoring of 7 questions. It does not know your genre, budget, build quality or audience.
It does not cover other ways to share a build, such as beta branches with keys, builds on other stores, or Early Access.
It does not estimate wishlists or sales from a demo. Use the demo conversion calculator for that.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a Steam Playtest and a demo?
A Playtest is a separate test app with a signup on your game page. You choose who gets in, you cannot charge for it, and it does not touch your reviews or wishlists. A demo is a separate free app that sells the game. It can have its own store page with reviews, appear where free games appear, and send one notice to your wishlisters.
Do I need a demo for Steam Next Fest?
Yes. Valve requires a publicly playable demo by the time the fest begins, and the game must not release before the fest ends. A Playtest does not count. Valve says a past or current Playtest does not affect eligibility, but it does not recommend having one live during the fest, because that splits players between two builds.
Does a demo send an email to my wishlisters?
Yes, once. When the demo becomes playable for the first time, you can trigger a notice, by email and in the mobile app, to everyone who has the full game on their wishlist, within 14 days. Turning the demo off and on again does not give you a second notice. Valve notes a two-week cooldown between wishlist notices for the same app.
Can Playtest players leave reviews?
Not on your game. A Playtest has its own App ID, so playtime, reviews, refunds and wishlists stay separate from the main game. Valve says a player who has only played the Playtest cannot review the real game. That makes a Playtest a safer place to test an unfinished build than a demo, which can collect reviews on its own store page.
Can I charge for a Playtest or turn a demo off?
You cannot charge for a Playtest, sell its keys or add paid items to it. Valve points developers who want to charge for an unfinished game to Early Access. A demo can be deactivated and reactivated at any time under Technical Tools, but players who downloaded it may still launch it unless it checks for a license through Steam.
Sources
- Valve, Steamworks documentation: Steam Playtest., read
- Valve, Steamworks documentation: Demos., read
- Valve, Steamworks documentation: Steam Next Fest., read
- Chris Zukowski, "What Steam's big demo update means for your marketing strategy", How To Market A Game, 31 July 2024., read
Last reviewed . All math runs in your browser. We do not send your inputs anywhere.
Next step
Manalens tracks the events you send from your Playtest or demo build, so you see sessions, retention and the step where players stop. See retention →