How many wishlists does a social post bring?

Usually very few. The best published test is small but clear. Zukowski asked 9 developers with unreleased games to tweet with tagged Steam links and the #screenshotsaturday hashtag. Together they got 5 wishlists. He says the sample is not statistically significant, but it matches what many developers see.

In his 2023 survey of over 100 games, Twitter came last of six sources, after festivals, TikTok, streamers, Reddit and the press. In 2022 he wrote that unless a game is very cute, even its most viral tweets only bring 50 to 70 wishlists.

Result from the April 2021 testValue
Developers who posted9
Wishlists in total5
Visitors not signed in to Steam, average90.35%
Wishlist rate of signed-in visitors, average8.43%
Best tweets2 wishlists each, from accounts with over 8K and 12K+ followers
A tweet with 38 likes, 15 retweets and 3 quote tweets0 wishlists

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 April 2021, 7 February 2022 and 14 March 2023).

Why do likes not turn into wishlists?

Because most people read social media on a phone and are not signed in to Steam there. To wishlist, they must sign in, so most of them go back to the feed. Steam can only credit a wishlist to your link when the visitor is signed in, and when the wishlist comes within 72 hours of the click.

Likes and reposts measure attention inside the platform. A wishlist needs a signed-in Steam account. The two are far apart, so a post with high engagement can still bring nothing on Steam.

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 April 2021); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

Which is better for game developers: X, Bluesky or Reddit?

Reddit ranked above Twitter in the 2023 survey. We found no public wishlist data for Bluesky, so test it yourself with tagged links. The platforms also differ in how they pass traffic. SparkToro found that public tweets passed a referrer in most or all cases, while Reddit posts lost a small share of referrers.

Bluesky posts have a limit of 300 characters. When you post a URL, the client fetches the page title, description and image once and stores them in the post as a link card. Bluesky says this reduces waves of automated traffic to the linked site, so your click data has less preview noise.

Manalens counts visits from x.com, t.co, bsky.app and reddit.com, or with those names in utm_source, as Organic Social. A tagged link keeps the post and campaign names as well.

Sources: How To Market A Game FAQ (14 March 2023); SparkToro (April 2023); Bluesky documentation, Action Intent Links and Posts in depth; Manalens attribution documentation.

What should I post to get wishlists?

Post short clips that show the hook of the game, with one clear request. Zukowski's TikTok case studies give advice that carries over to any feed: hook people in the first second, show what makes the game unique, and keep the call to action big and clear. Feeds move fast, so one idea per post works best.

Ask for one action only. Zukowski suggests that a link to your Discord may convert better than a link to Steam, because people often stay signed in to Discord on a phone. That is his hypothesis, not a test result. Measure both links and decide with your own numbers.

  • Show gameplay, not a logo or a cutscene.
  • Put the game name in the text, so people can search for it on a PC later.
  • Use one link per post, tagged for the platform and the post type.
  • Pin your best post with its own link, and compare it with your weekly posts.

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 April 2021 and 7 February 2022).

How do I tag each post?

Give every platform its own utm_source, and every post type its own utm_campaign. Zukowski used utm_source=my_twitter with campaigns such as screenshotsaturday, pinned_tweet and wishlistwednesday. Steam hides UTM combinations with few visits, so keep the list of values short.

  1. Write down your values first: utm_source of x, bluesky or reddit; utm_medium of social; utm_campaign of screenshotsaturday, pinned or devlog.
  2. Create one short link per source and campaign in Links. Bulk create takes up to 100 rows from a spreadsheet.
  3. Click Test a UTM Link in Steamworks for each new link.
  4. Post with the short link. Use the same link every Saturday, so the numbers add up in one row.
  5. After 4 days, download the Steamworks UTM report and import it under Settings, Integrations, Steam.
  6. Once a month, compare clicks, UTM wishlists and the wishlist rate per source and campaign.

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 April 2021); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Manalens short links documentation.

How do I judge Screenshot Saturday over a month?

Judge it on wishlists per hour of work and on the links it earns, not on likes. Add up four Saturdays per platform, because one week is too small to read. If a month brings fewer wishlists than one festival day, spend the time on press or creator outreach instead.

Social posts also have value that UTM cannot see. A press writer or a creator may find the game through a post. Keep a note of any coverage that started from a post, next to the numbers.

Read the tracked share first. If it stays near 9.65%, the share in the 2021 test (our arithmetic: 100% minus 90.35%), most of your visitors cannot wishlist from the link. Then the wishlist rate of signed-in visitors tells you more about the post than the total does. A low rate with a high tracked share means the post reached the wrong people.

NumberFormulaUse
Clickslink_clicked events per short linkInterest in the post
Tracked shareTracked visits / total visits in the UTM reportHow many visitors were signed in to Steam
Wishlist rateUTM wishlists / tracked visitsFit between the post and the game
Wishlists per hourUTM wishlists / hours spent on postsCompare with other channels

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 April 2021 and 14 March 2023); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

Where can I see wishlists per post?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Tag each post with a short link, import the Steam UTM report, and read clicks and Steam wishlists per platform and campaign next to your website traffic.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Does Screenshot Saturday still bring wishlists?

Rarely many. In the 2021 test, 9 developers got 5 wishlists in total from #screenshotsaturday tweets. It can still help you meet press, creators and other developers. Tag your Saturday link with its own utm_campaign, add up a month of results, and compare it with the time it takes.

Should my posts link to Steam or to Discord?

Test both. A Steam link counts wishlists only from visitors signed in to Steam, and most phone users are not. Zukowski suggests Discord may convert better on phones, but he did not test it. Give each its own short link and compare clicks, joins and wishlists after a month.

Is Bluesky better than X for indie games?

We found no public wishlist data that compares them. Bluesky stores link cards in the post, which cuts preview bot traffic, and public tweets pass a referrer in most cases. Post the same clip on both with separate tagged links, then compare UTM wishlists per platform after 4 days.

Why does my post have many likes but no wishlists?

Likes happen inside the app, and wishlists need a signed-in Steam account. In the 2021 test, a tweet with 38 likes and 15 retweets brought 0 wishlists. Most readers are on a phone and leave before they sign in. Judge posts by tracked wishlists and lift, not engagement.

Sources and implementation