Which short video platform brings the most wishlists?

TikTok has the strongest public record for indie games. Chris Zukowski surveyed over 100 games and ranked the sources of their wishlists: festivals, then TikTok (if the game is the right type), then streamers, Reddit, the press and Twitter. In the same FAQ he says Instagram does not work for visibility in his experience. We found no public wishlist data for YouTube Shorts.

The published TikTok cases vary a lot. The table copies views and wishlists from How To Market A Game. The last column is our arithmetic. The spread is more than 20 times between the best and the worst case, so one viral video does not predict the next.

GameTikTok viewsWishlists from the videoWishlists per 1,000 views (our arithmetic)
I Just Want to be Single!!, visual novelMore than 571,000Over 2,900About 5.1
FREERIDE715k13,000About 18.2
The Matriarch4.5 million10,000About 2.2
Farewell North950k830About 0.9

Sources: How To Market A Game FAQ (14 March 2023); How To Market A Game (7 February 2022 and 14 February 2022).

How do TikTok, YouTube Shorts and Reels differ?

YouTube Shorts and Reels both take vertical videos of up to 3 minutes, but the platforms differ most on links. YouTube makes URLs in Shorts descriptions and comments not clickable, to reduce spam and scams. TikTok shows a website link on a profile only for personal accounts with at least 1,000 followers, or for business accounts. So on every platform, the profile link does most of the work.

Music is another difference. A TikTok business account gets the Commercial Music Library only, not the general library. On YouTube, a Short over one minute with an active copyright claim is blocked globally. Use your own soundtrack when you can.

PlatformLengthClickable linkNotes
YouTube ShortsUp to 3 minutes for square or vertical videos uploaded on or after 15 October 2024Channel profile links and a related video link to your own YouTube video; not URLs in the descriptionShorts can earn from the Shorts revenue sharing model
TikTokNot checked for this guideA profile website link with 1,000 followers, or with a business accountBusiness accounts use the Commercial Music Library only
Instagram ReelsUp to 3 minutes since 18 January 2025The profile linkPublic profile links usually pass a referrer

Sources: YouTube Help, three-minute Shorts, sharing links and related video pages; TikTok Support, account types; Adam Mosseri on Threads (18 January 2025).

Why does TikTok traffic look like Direct traffic?

Because TikTok sends no referrer. In SparkToro's April 2023 test, 100% of visits from TikTok reached the site marked as direct, with no referral data. YouTube and public Instagram profile links passed referral data in most or all cases. Instagram direct messages lost 30%.

Many viewers also never click. They watch on a phone and then search for the game on a PC. For FREERIDE, 48% of the traffic around the viral video came from people who searched for the game on Steam, and 33% came through a Linktree link. For I Just Want to be Single!!, the developer said a Steam UTM link in the TikTok bio tracked only about 10% of the actual traffic.

So a TikTok campaign always looks worse in link data than it is. Measure the clicks you can see, and measure the lift in daily wishlists that the clicks cannot explain.

Sources: SparkToro (April 2023); How To Market A Game (7 February 2022 and 14 February 2022).

Should I post the same clip on all three platforms?

Yes as a test, but expect native cuts to win. Kyle Banks, the developer of Farewell North, posted his YouTube videos to TikTok as they were, and they did poorly. TikTok specific videos went viral. The Matriarch went viral after several failed recuts of its trailer; the cut that worked had shorter clips, sped up to 130%, with shorter text.

You do not need to dance on camera. In 2024 Zukowski wrote that the most successful TikToks he sees are sliced up trailers with captions. He also says it is often more effective to get a real TikTok creator to cover the game than to post yourself.

Post the same clip on all three in the same week, each with its own link. Then compare clicks, UTM wishlists and lift per platform after 4 days. Keep the platform that wins, and make native cuts for it.

Sources: How To Market A Game (14 February 2022 and 26 September 2024).

Where can I compare the three platforms?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Create one short link per platform, add the QR code to your end card, and import the Steam UTM report. Then you see clicks, Steam wishlists and installs for TikTok, Shorts and Reels side by side.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Is TikTok better than YouTube Shorts for indie games?

For wishlists, the public evidence favors TikTok. Chris Zukowski's survey of over 100 games ranked TikTok second only to festivals, and we found no comparable data for Shorts. Shorts can still work for your game, so post the same clip on both with separate links and compare after 4 days.

Why does my analytics show TikTok visits as Direct?

TikTok sends no referrer. SparkToro found that all of its test visits from TikTok arrived marked as direct. Put a short link with utm_source=tiktok in your TikTok profile. Then each click carries the platform name, and Manalens counts it as Organic Social instead of Direct.

Can I put a clickable link in a YouTube Short?

Not in the description or comments. YouTube makes those URLs not clickable to reduce spam. Use the channel profile links, and add a related video that links each Short to a longer video of yours. That longer video can carry a clickable link to your Steam page in its description.

How many wishlists does a viral TikTok bring?

It varies widely. Published cases range from 830 wishlists for 950k views to 13,000 wishlists for 715k views. By our arithmetic that is about 0.9 to 18.2 wishlists per 1,000 views. The game and the hook matter more than the view count, so measure your own ratio.

Sources and implementation