Do wishlists from different sources convert differently?

Yes, and the gap can be large. Melos Han-Tani read the monthly wishlist cohort data in the Steam wishlist dashboard after the Danchi Days launch. This data shows how many wishlists from one month went on to become purchases. The September 2024 cohort, the reveal month, converted at 7.4% in week one. The July 2026 cohort converted at 1.0%.

He then grouped the months by what drove them and gave each type a rating, with announcement period wishlists as 100. These ratings are his own judgment from one game, not a Steam benchmark. Still, they match other reports. GameDiscoverCo quoted the Furnish Master post-mortem, which said that the wishlists from ads were of worse quality and converted into sales less well.

Relative conversion of wishlist types for Danchi Days, as rated by its developer (announcement period = 100).
Wishlist typeRatingWhy, in the developer's view
Announcement period100Fans of past games buy the next game
Streamer audience60They saw the game played
Personal Calendar40They plan to buy soon, but wishlist many games at once
Organic, no marketing beat40Loose interest, often from search
Showcase viewers25The game is far from sale, and viewers wishlist many games
Ad clickers15Lowest of all, even below showcases

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).

Why do showcase and ad wishlists convert less?

Because these wishlists cost the player almost nothing and often mean "maybe later". Chris Zukowski points out that Valve made wishlisting easier, for example with a wishlist button in hover tooltips. So a wishlist became more like a bookmark. He also says that developers have long suspected that festival wishlists convert less well.

Han-Tani gives two more reasons from his launch. Showcases feature games that will not be on sale for a while, and viewers wishlist many games in one sitting. And when the art promises one genre and the game is another, players wishlist the look and then skip the purchase. He thinks many Danchi Days wishlisters saw cozy art and expected cozy game systems.

A wishlist from someone who played your demo, watched a long stream or bought your last game carries more intent. A wishlist from a fast scroll past a trailer carries less. The count is the same in Steamworks, but the value is not.

Sources: How To Market A Game (13 October 2026); Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026).

How big is the drop in wishlist value across Steam?

About half for first-month sales. In How To Market A Game's survey of 160 games, 34 released from 2020 to 2022 and 126 from 2023 to 2025. Inven Global reports the chart values: first-month sales per wishlist fell from 0.45 to 0.22. At one year the gap was smaller, 0.99 against 0.70.

Wishlists still predict sales. The R squared between launch wishlists and first-month units was 0.77 for the early era and 0.72 for the later era, which Zukowski calls noise for this sample. GameDiscoverCo found a median of 0.15x week-one sales per launch wishlist for games with more than 25,000 wishlists, and it counts all week-one sales in that ratio.

So the source mix matters on top of a general drop. If your list is heavy with festival, showcase or ad wishlists, expect to land below these medians.

Sales per wishlist by release era in the How To Market A Game survey, as reported by Inven Global.
Window after launch2020 to 2022 releases2023 to 2025 releases
First month0.450.22
Six months0.820.43
One year0.990.70

Sources: How To Market A Game (13 October 2026); Inven Global (15 October 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).

How do I measure conversion by source for my own game?

Steam does not report conversion by source at launch, so you build it from cohorts and a log. Steam counts UTM conversions only within 72 hours of a tracked visit, so the UTM report cannot tell you which wishlists bought at launch months later. Use the add month as the link instead.

  1. Keep a log of every marketing beat with its dates: reveal, showcases, festivals, creator videos, ad flights.
  2. Tag every outside link with UTM parameters, so the UTM report shows which source brought the adds in each period.
  3. Record daily wishlist adds. Mark which days belong to which beat, and which days are a quiet baseline.
  4. After launch, read the monthly cohort data in the Steam wishlist dashboard: purchases from each month of adds.
  5. Divide each cohort's purchases by its adds. This is a cohort conversion rate.
  6. Match each cohort to the main source of that month, and compare the rates.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Steamworks Wishlists documentation.

What are the limits of cohort conversion?

Cohorts mix sources, and Steam does not tell you which month a deleted wishlist came from. Han-Tani notes that you can see the adds of a month, but not how many of those adds were later deleted. So each cohort rate is a little lower than the truth.

A month with a showcase also has organic adds and maybe a creator video. Pick months where one beat clearly dominates, and treat the rest as mixed. Older cohorts also had more time to delete, so compare months close in age when you can.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026).

How do I forecast launch sales with a mixed wishlist list?

Weight each part of the list by its own conversion rate instead of one blended rate. Here is a worked example. The rates are made up for the example, inside the 1.0% to 7.4% range that Danchi Days saw. They are not benchmarks.

In this example, a flat 7% rate would predict 2,800 sales. The weighted forecast is 1,250, less than half. Our arithmetic. Replace the example rates with your own cohort rates as soon as you have them, or with rates from a past game.

Example weighted forecast for 40,000 launch wishlists (example rates, our arithmetic).
Source of wishlistsWishlistsExample week-one rateExpected sales
Reveal and fans10,0007%700
Showcases and festivals20,0002%400
Paid ads10,0001.5%150
Total40,0003.1% blended1,250

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026); our arithmetic.

Should I stop buying showcase and ad wishlists?

No, but value them lower. Divide the cost per wishlist by the conversion rate of that source to get a cost per buyer. A cheap ad wishlist can cost more per buyer than a costly creator wishlist.

Danchi Days spent $7,000 on Reddit ads over 108 days, at $1.79 to $1.94 per wishlist. After launch, Han-Tani wrote that he would not recommend ads unless the game costs $25 or more and sits in a conventional genre with higher conversion. Watch other signals too. He says slow Steam follower growth and no big social moments were early warnings that the wishlists would not convert.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026, edited 31 October 2026); Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026).

Where can I see wishlists by source over time?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Import the Steam UTM report to see wishlists per source and campaign, and sync daily wishlist adds and purchases with a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access). Then you can mark your beats on one timeline and compare cohorts.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Which wishlists convert best on Steam?

In the Danchi Days cohort data, wishlists from the reveal month converted best, at 7.4% in week one. The developer rated fan wishlists highest, then streamer audiences, then Personal Calendar and organic adds. Showcase and ad wishlists came last. This is one game, so check your own cohorts before you rely on it.

Can Steam tell me which source a buyer came from?

Only within 72 hours of a tracked visit from a UTM link. The UTM report counts wishlists and purchases after a click, but not a launch purchase months later. For launch, use the monthly wishlist cohort data and your own log of marketing beats to estimate conversion by source.

Do wishlists still predict sales?

Yes. In How To Market A Game's survey of 160 games, launch wishlists still correlated strongly with first-month units, with an R squared of 0.72 for 2023 to 2025 releases. Each wishlist sells fewer copies than before, but games with more wishlists still sell more. The source mix explains part of the spread.

How do I value a wishlist from an ad?

Divide the cost per wishlist by the conversion rate you expect for ad wishlists. That gives a cost per buyer, which you can compare with your net revenue per copy. Danchi Days paid $1.79 to $1.94 per Reddit ad wishlist, and its developer later found ad cohorts converted worst.

Sources and implementation