What is cost per wishlist?

Spend divided by wishlists. The hard part is the bottom of the fraction. You can divide by the wishlists in the Steam UTM report, by the lift over your baseline, or by all wishlist adds in the campaign window. The three give very different answers for the same campaign.

Green Man Gaming showed the gap in one campaign: the UTM report gave £3.30 per wishlist, and the lift during a period with no other paid media gave £1.71. Always write down which version you quote.

Two ways to calculate cost per wishlist, and the bias of each.
VersionFormulaBias
TrackedSpend / UTM wishlistsToo high: UTM misses players who switch device or are not signed in
LiftSpend / (wishlists in window minus baseline)Close, if nothing else changed in the window
WindowSpend / all wishlists in windowToo low: it credits every other source to the campaign

Sources: Green Man Gaming (24 February 2026); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

What cost per wishlist do indie campaigns report?

Most published Reddit campaigns land between $1 and $3 per wishlist, with one test near $5 on tracked wishlists. The table copies each figure from its source. Where we computed a ratio, the row says so.

Published cost per wishlist from indie campaigns.
Game and genreChannel and periodSpendWishlistsCost per wishlist
This Grand Life 2, life simMostly Reddit, some Twitter and Facebook, 2024$4,365About 4,000$1.10 average, $0.80 to $2.50 by ad group
Danchi Days, cross-genre adventureReddit, 20 December 2025 to 7 April 2026$7,0003,000 UTM; 3,600 to 3,900 estimated$1.79 to $1.94 (developer estimate)
Ruinarch, god simReddit, mid 2020About $60 a dayNot givenAbout $2.50 (rough estimate)
Only Way is Down, rage platformerReddit, before the April 2025 launchAbout $700237$2.95
Glyphica, roguelite typing gameReddit, 27 May to 2 June 2024$50091 UTM; 159 above the control week$5.49 tracked, $3.14 on lift (our arithmetic)

Sources: Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Only Way is Down post-mortem; Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024); Game Developer, The Road to Ruinarch (24 August 2020).

Does genre change cost per wishlist?

Yes, through how fast an ad can show what the game is. Melos Han-Tani says Danchi Days struggled to get below $1.50 per wishlist because it mixes genres, so he often needed 8 to 10 clicks per wishlist at $0.15 to $0.20 a click. He has seen simulation games go below $1.

This Grand Life 2 had dedicated genre communities. Its best subreddits, built around similar tycoon games, had click-through rates of 2.8% to 5.8%, against an average of 1.5% to 2% on relevant game subreddits. A game with a clear niche can buy cheaper attention.

Five games are not a benchmark by genre. Use them to set a test budget, not to predict your own number.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Game World Observer (31 May 2024).

What do creators and showcases cost per wishlist?

Few public cases give both a fee and a wishlist count for creators. Ruinarch got 2,891 wishlists in one day from an unpaid SplatterCatGaming video, which a fee-based campaign cannot plan for. For paid creator content, Nick Lombardi estimated Clair Obscur views at $59 per thousand on YouTube Shorts and $423 per thousand on Twitch. Our creator cost guide turns those into cost per wishlist.

For showcases, How To Market A Game published the median Steam follower gain per showcase in spring 2025, and the list price per minute. The median cost per follower ranged from $16 at triple-i to $337 at Galaxies. Zukowski multiplies followers by about 9 to 10 to estimate wishlists.

Sources: Game Developer, The Road to Ruinarch (24 August 2020); Nick Lombardi (5 May 2025); How To Market A Game (23 September 2025).

What is a wishlist worth?

The sales it brings, minus Steam's share, taxes and refunds. GameDiscoverCo's median is 0.15x first-week sales per wishlist for launches with more than 25,000 wishlists in the year to August 2025, and 0.10x for games above $10. Melos Han-Tani uses 0.6 of the price as what remains after Steam's cut, VAT and refunds.

Our arithmetic with those two numbers: a $20 game at 0.10x earns 0.10 x $20 x 0.6 = $1.20 per wishlist in launch week. A wishlist keeps converting in later sales, so its full value is higher, but you do not know by how much until after launch. If your cost per wishlist is above the first-week value, the campaign must pay back later.

Formula (our arithmetic)

first-week value per wishlist = conversion x price x 0.6
example: 0.10 x $20 x 0.6 = $1.20

Sources: GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

Are cheap wishlists as good as other wishlists?

Not always. After launch, Melos Han-Tani wrote that the Reddit wishlists for Danchi Days converted at a lower rate than other wishlists. The game converted 2.2% of 55,000 wishlists in its first week, while players who wishlisted soon after the store page went live bought at 7.4%. GameDiscoverCo also quotes the Furnish Master developer: wishlists from ads were of worse quality and converted less well.

So compare channels on sales per wishlist after launch, not only on cost per wishlist before it. Steam does not split conversion by source, but you can compare the conversion of weeks with heavy ads against weeks without.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (edit of 31 October 2026); AUTOMATON (12 November 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).

How do I compute my own cost per wishlist?

Use both the tracked and the lift version, from the same dates.

  1. Write down the average daily wishlist adds for the 7 to 14 days before the campaign.
  2. Tag every ad, creator or post with its own utm_content.
  3. Run the campaign, and avoid other beats in the same days if you can.
  4. Wait 4 days after the last click, so Steam finalizes the UTM conversions.
  5. Divide spend by UTM wishlists, then divide spend by the wishlists above the baseline.
  6. Record both numbers, the dates and anything else that happened in the window.

Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics and Wishlists documentation.

Why does cost per wishlist change during a campaign?

Because audiences tire and tests fail. Over four periods of Danchi Days ads, Melos Han-Tani reported $1.88, $1.70, $2.25 and $1.92 per wishlist. The best period came from a few manual ads that did well in the US, UK, Australia and Canada. The worst included failed tests in Japanese subreddits and other countries.

He also uses the share of visits that wishlist as an early warning. When an ad falls below 20%, it is either a weak ad or it has run too long and reaches the same people again. Check cost per wishlist per ad every few days, not once per campaign.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

Where can I track cost per wishlist over time?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Import the Steam UTM report and sync daily wishlist adds with a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access). Then compare UTM wishlists by campaign with all wishlist adds for the same days. Spend is not imported, so divide by your own spend sheet.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cost per wishlist for an indie game?

One below what a wishlist earns you. At the GameDiscoverCo median of 0.10x for games above $10, a $20 game earns about $1.20 per wishlist in launch week after a 0.6 net share. Published Reddit campaigns report $1.10 to $2.95, with one test near $5 tracked.

Why is my Steam UTM cost per wishlist so high?

Because the UTM report counts only signed-in players who act within 72 hours in the same browser. In one Green Man Gaming campaign, UTM saw 24% of the wishlists. Measure the lift over your baseline as well, and quote both numbers.

Is there a cost per wishlist benchmark by genre?

No public dataset gives one. A few developers have published single campaigns, and their games differ in price, art and timing. Simulation and tycoon games with clear niches report lower costs than cross-genre games, but run your own test before you plan a budget.

Should I use the UTM or the lift cost per wishlist?

Use both and label them. The UTM version is a floor on results, so it overstates cost. The lift version counts players who searched Steam later, but it also counts anything else that happened in the same days. Green Man Gaming reported £3.30 on UTM and £1.71 on lift for one campaign.

Sources and implementation