Which ad platform gives the cheapest wishlists?

Reddit has the most evidence, and it ranges from about $1 to $3 per wishlist. For other platforms we found no published indie campaign with spend and a wishlist count that we could verify. That is a gap in public data, not proof that the platforms are worse.

Published indie results by ad platform.
PlatformPublished indie resultSource
Reddit$1.10 average, $0.80 to $2.50 by ad group (This Grand Life 2)Game World Observer, May 2024
Reddit$1.79 to $1.94 per estimated wishlist (Danchi Days)Melos Han-Tani, April 2026
Reddit$2.95, about 12,000 clicks for 237 wishlists (Only Way is Down)Developer post-mortem
Reddit$500 for 91 UTM wishlists (Glyphica)Squeaky Wheel, June 2024
TwitterTerrible click-through and a lower wishlist rate than Reddit for the same audiences (This Grand Life 2)Game World Observer, May 2024
TikTokAbout $100 for 100,000 views with very low engagement, no wishlist count (Only Way is Down)Developer post-mortem

Sources: Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Only Way is Down post-mortem; Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024).

Why can the ad platform not see my wishlists?

Because Steam runs no ad pixels. Steam stopped supporting Google Analytics on store pages after Google moved to GA4 in July 2023, and it gives no conversion feed to Meta, Reddit, TikTok or Google. The ad dashboard sees clicks. Only Steamworks sees the wishlist.

So set the campaign goal to traffic or landing page views, and measure wishlists in Steamworks with UTM links. Do not trust a conversion number in the ad dashboard for a Steam page.

Sources: Steamworks Google Analytics documentation; Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

How should I target Reddit ads for a game?

Target communities of games like yours, not general gaming. Reddit community targeting reaches people who subscribed to a subreddit or visited it in the last 28 days, and the ads can show anywhere they browse. Reddit recommends at least 15 communities per ad group.

This Grand Life 2 found its best click-through rates in subreddits of similar tycoon games, from 2.8% to 5.8%. Its developer advises against r/Games and r/Gaming. Melos Han-Tani got his best month for Danchi Days from ads in CozyGamers, PixelArt, Undertale and OMORI communities.

Reddit turns on automated targeting by default. It can show your ad beyond the communities you chose, so watch the community report and the wishlist rate per ad group.

Sources: Reddit Ads Help, Reddit Audiences; Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

Should I target mobile or desktop for a PC game?

Test mobile; do not exclude it. For This Grand Life 2, mobile gave 90% of tracked visits and 96% of tracked wishlists. In the Glyphica test, a desktop-only ad group converted 14% of tracked visits to wishlists, against 27% and 30% for the mobile-inclusive groups, and its clicks cost $0.19 against $0.07 and $0.10.

Valve also helps mobile players: a visitor who is not signed in sees a banner to open the page in the Steam mobile app, and Steam can then follow the visit to a wishlist.

Sources: Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

How do I run a small ad test?

Spend enough to learn, tag every ad, and stop losers early. Melos Han-Tani suggests $500 to $1,000 as a minimum for Reddit.

  1. Write the hook as the ad title. This Grand Life 2 found that the hook beats the game name.
  2. Give each ad group its own utm_campaign and each ad its own utm_content, with utm_source set to the platform, for example redditad.
  3. Record the daily wishlist baseline for the week before.
  4. Run 2 to 4 ad groups with genre communities.
  5. Every 2 to 3 days, divide UTM wishlists by visits for each ad. Melos aims for 20% or more. This Grand Life 2 stopped an ad with 0 wishlists from 100 tracked visits.
  6. After the test, wait 4 days, then compute the tracked and the lift cost per wishlist.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Game World Observer (31 May 2024); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

When are paid ads not worth it?

When the game is cheap, hard to show in one image, or the wishlists do not buy. Melos Han-Tani says ads are harder to pay back for games at $10 or less. After the Danchi Days launch, he added that its Reddit wishlists converted at a lower rate than other wishlists, and that Reddit ads are likely not worth it unless the game has a very obvious focused niche.

GameDiscoverCo quotes the Furnish Master developer making the same point: wishlists from ads were of worse quality and converted into sales less effectively. Ads can still help a game reach Steam's Popular Upcoming list, which was the goal for This Grand Life 2.

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026, edited 31 October 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025); Game World Observer (31 May 2024).

What does the Manalens dashboard add to an ad test?

One view of UTM wishlists per ad, all wishlist adds per day, and the visits to your own site from the same ads. Import the Steamworks UTM CSV and group by content to compare ads. The automatic Steam sync is in early access: with a Steamworks Financial API key, it adds all wishlist adds and deletes per day and country, so the baseline and the lift sit next to the UTM rows.

It does not import ad spend and does not compute cost per wishlist. Keep spend in a sheet and divide.

Sources: Manalens Steam and attribution documentation.

Which UTM values should I use for ads?

One source per platform, one campaign per ad group and one content value per ad. Melos Han-Tani sets utm_source to redditad, uses utm_campaign for ad groups and utm_content for each ad, such as 1A, 1B and 1C. Steam then gives a row per ad, and you can stop the weak ones.

Add a paid medium as well, such as utm_medium=paidsocial or cpc. Manalens classifies a paid medium, or an ad click ID such as rdt_cid from Reddit or ttclid from TikTok, as paid traffic. So visits from the same ads to your own website land in Paid Social or Paid Search, not in Organic Social.

A tagged ad link (480 is an example app ID)

https://store.steampowered.com/app/480/?utm_source=redditad&utm_medium=paidsocial&utm_campaign=cozy_group&utm_content=1A

Sources: Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026); Manalens attribution documentation.

How do I start an ad test?

Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Build one tagged Steam link per ad, import the UTM report after the test, and compare ads by wishlist rate and lift.

Sources: Manalens product documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Are Reddit ads worth it for indie games?

They can be for games with a clear niche and a price above $10. Published campaigns report $1.10 to $2.95 per wishlist. Danchi Days later found that its Reddit wishlists converted worse than its other wishlists, so check conversion after launch, not only cost before it.

Can I optimize Meta or Reddit ads for Steam wishlists?

No. Steam sends no conversion signal to ad platforms, and it stopped supporting Google Analytics on store pages in 2023. Optimize the campaign for traffic or landing page views. Then read the wishlists per ad in the Steamworks UTM report, and stop ads with a low wishlist rate.

How much should I spend on a first ad test?

Melos Han-Tani suggests $500 to $1,000 on Reddit. That is enough to test a few audiences and ads. Stop ads with no wishlists after about 100 tracked visits, as the This Grand Life 2 developer did, and measure both the UTM and the lift cost per wishlist.

Should I run ads before or after launch?

Before launch, ads buy wishlists that may convert later, and they can help a game reach Popular Upcoming. After launch, they send players to a page with reviews and a buy button. Either way, tag each ad and compare the cost with what a wishlist or a sale earns you.

Sources and implementation