Which numbers do publishers ask for?
Wishlists, demo or playtest metrics, and a plan for the money. In an App2Top roundtable, four publishers listed what a team should have ready. All asked for a build or demo and a gameplay video. Polden Publishing added a Steam page with the wishlist count and a playtest with prototype metrics.
Polden also said that good metrics such as CCU, retention and median playtime are extra cards in negotiations. Skystone Games asked for a budget and burn rate, and Indie GO Fund asked for a profit and loss document. So the numbers sit next to the build, not instead of it.
| Number | Where you get it | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Wishlists, net of deletes | Steamworks wishlist report | Demand today |
| Wishlists per day, by week | Steamworks wishlist report | Whether demand still grows |
| Wishlists by source | Steamworks UTM Analytics | Which channels work, and at what cost |
| Demo or playtest median playtime | Steamworks, or your own game events | Whether players enjoy the game |
| Early retention (time buckets, D1) | Your own game events | Whether players come back |
| Peak CCU in a demo or playtest | Steamworks or SteamDB | Size of the active audience |
| Wishlists by country | Steamworks regional sales report | Where the audience lives |
Sources: App2Top roundtable (9 October 2025).
How many wishlists do publishers expect?
It differs by publisher, so read each one as a single data point. Polden Publishing tracks two key metrics after a demo: wishlists and median playtime. Its CEO wrote that a game should usually have at least 50k wishlists by the demo stage, and a median playtime above 40 minutes, ideally above 50.
Other publishers read momentum, not one number. Fireshine Games, the publisher of Far Far West, says it looks at follower growth, Discord activity, playtest turnout and how much people talk about a game. Its CEO Brian Foote said that there is no single silver bullet when it comes to data.
So show the trend, not only the total. A flat line at 30,000 wishlists tells a publisher less than a smaller count that still grows every week.
Sources: Kirill Oreshkin, Polden Publishing (1 June 2026); GameDev.net, from GamesIndustry.biz (19 May 2026).
Why do publishers care where wishlists came from?
Because the source changes what a wishlist is worth at launch. GameDiscoverCo found a median of 0.15x first-week sales per wishlist for games that launched with more than 25k wishlists. For games above $10, the median fell to 0.10x. Valve itself says there is no formula to predict sales from wishlists.
A publisher will build a forecast from your count. With 50,000 wishlists and the 0.10x median, the forecast is 5,000 first-week units (our arithmetic). If 30,000 of those wishlists came from cheap ads in one week, the publisher will want to know, because those players found the game in a different way.
Show the UTM report by source, with the cost per wishlist for every paid channel. Keep tracked and estimated wishlists in separate columns. A publisher who finds an inflated number later stops trusting the other numbers too.
Sources: GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025); Steamworks Wishlists documentation; Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.
Which demo and playtest numbers matter?
Median playtime first, then how many players are still in the game after set times. One developer wrote that a publisher asked for these demo retention targets: 75% to 80% of players at 10 minutes, 30% to 50% at 30 minutes, and 10% to 15% at 2 hours. Their own demo met them.
Large playtests count as proof too. Simon Carless wrote that Far Far West ran two Steam playtests that hit 2,400 and 9,400 CCU, and ranked 5th by unique players of about 3,500 games in the February 2026 Next Fest. GameDiscoverCo estimated it launched with close to 650k wishlists.
| Metric | Target | Who said it |
|---|---|---|
| Wishlists at the demo stage | At least 50k | Polden Publishing CEO |
| Demo median playtime | Above 40 minutes, ideally above 50 | Polden Publishing CEO |
| Players still playing at 10 minutes | 75% to 80% | A publisher, as reported by New to Narrative |
| Players still playing at 30 minutes | 30% to 50% | A publisher, as reported by New to Narrative |
| Players still playing at 2 hours | 10% to 15% | A publisher, as reported by New to Narrative |
Sources: New to Narrative (14 July 2026); Kirill Oreshkin, Polden Publishing (1 June 2026); Simon Carless (8 May 2026).
What goes in a pitch data room?
Raw exports with dates, not screenshots. A data room is one shared folder that a publisher can check without asking you for each file.
- Export daily wishlist adds, deletes and purchases for the whole life of the page.
- Export the UTM Analytics report, grouped by source and campaign.
- Add the wishlist split by country from the regional report.
- Add the demo and playtest numbers: players, median playtime, and the time buckets above.
- Add a one page sheet of paid spend by channel, with cost per wishlist.
- Add your comps: three to five similar games with price, reviews and launch date.
- Add the budget, the burn rate and the date of every file.
Sources: Steamworks Wishlists and UTM Analytics documentation; App2Top roundtable (9 October 2025).
How do I keep the numbers honest?
Report net numbers, label paid numbers and date everything. Net wishlists are adds minus deletes. Paid wishlists need the spend next to them. A spike from one creator video needs a note, so nobody reads it as the normal rate.
Say what you cannot measure. Steam counts a UTM conversion only for visitors signed in to Steam, so the source table is a sample. Say so in the file, and show the total daily wishlists next to it.
Sources: Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation; Steamworks Wishlists documentation.
Where can I collect these numbers in one place?
Manalens is the analytics and growth engine built for games. Import the Steam UTM report and sync daily wishlists and sales per country with a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access). Add the Unity, Godot or web SDK to your demo to get playtime, retention and funnels next to them, and export any chart as CSV for the data room.
Sources: Manalens product documentation.
Frequently asked questions
How many wishlists do I need before I pitch a publisher?
There is no single number. Polden Publishing wrote that a game should usually have at least 50k wishlists by the demo stage. Fireshine Games says it also reads follower growth, Discord activity and playtest turnout. Pitch with a build and your trend, and show where the wishlists came from.
Which demo metric do publishers look at first?
Usually median playtime, because it shows whether players enjoy the game. Polden Publishing named above 40 minutes as its target, and ideally above 50. Some publishers also ask how many players are still playing at 10 minutes, 30 minutes and 2 hours. Track those buckets with your own game events.
Should I share bought wishlists in a pitch?
Yes, but label them. Show the spend and the cost per wishlist for each paid channel next to the organic numbers. Wishlists from different sources can convert differently at launch, and a publisher builds a forecast from your count. Hidden paid spikes cost more trust than they gain.
Can a small wishlist count still get a publisher deal?
Yes, if other signals are strong. Fireshine Games says a game with very few Steam wishlists might be doing incredible things on TikTok, and it reads follower growth, Discord activity and playtest turnout. Show the growth rate and the demo playtime, and explain where your audience lives today.
What should I not put in the first email to a publisher?
Long documents. Send the build or demo link, a gameplay video, a short deck and the headline numbers with dates. Keep the full data room ready and share it when the publisher asks. App2Top publishers asked for the build, the video and a clear request first.
Sources and implementation
- App2Top: What you need to have on hand when looking for a publisher, a roundtable with publishers (Alexander Semenov, 9 October 2025) ↗
- Kirill Oreshkin (CEO, Polden Publishing): We are building a data-driven indie game publisher (LinkedIn, 1 June 2026) ↗
- New to Narrative: Highs and Lows, Next Fest Edition (Turbo Hermit, 14 July 2026) ↗
- GameDev.net: How Fireshine Games backed a winner with Far Far West (from GamesIndustry.biz, 19 May 2026) ↗
- Simon Carless: Far Far West launch notes from the GameDiscoverCo newsletter (LinkedIn, 8 May 2026) ↗
- GameDiscoverCo: The state of Steam wishlist 'conversions': 2024-2025 (Simon Carless, 17 October 2025) ↗
- Steamworks documentation: Wishlists (Valve, read 18 November 2026) ↗
- Steamworks documentation: UTM Analytics (Valve, read 18 November 2026) ↗