How do I calculate effective cost per wishlist?

Divide spend by the lift. The lift is the wishlist adds in the campaign window minus the adds you would expect without the campaign. Take that expected number from a quiet baseline period of the same length just before the campaign.

Keep the tracked version next to it: spend divided by the wishlists in the Steam UTM report. The tracked version counts only signed-in players who wishlist within 72 hours of a click, so it is a worst case. Always label which version you quote.

Two ways to calculate cost per wishlist
VersionFormulaBias
TrackedSpend / UTM wishlistsToo high: UTM misses players who switch device or are not signed in
Effective (lift)Spend / (wishlist adds in window minus baseline adds)Close, if nothing else changed in the window

Sources: Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024); Green Man Gaming (24 February 2026); Steamworks UTM Analytics documentation.

What does a worked example look like?

Example: Glyphica spent $500 on Reddit ads from 27 May to 2 June 2024. The control week before had 227 wishlists and the ad week had 386, so the lift was 159. Steam UTM attributed 91 wishlists to the ads.

Our arithmetic: the tracked cost is $500 / 91 = $5.49 per wishlist. The effective cost is $500 / 159 = $3.14 per wishlist. The same campaign looks almost twice as cheap when you count the wishlists that Steam could not follow.

Sources: Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024).

Why does effective cost per wishlist matter for indie PC and web games?

Because the tracked number can make a working channel look like a failure. In one Green Man Gaming campaign, the UTM report saw only 24% of the wishlists that the lift showed. Many players see an ad or a video on their phone and wishlist later in the Steam client.

Compare the effective cost with what a wishlist earns you. GameDiscoverCo found a median of 0.10x first-week sales per wishlist for games above $10. Melos Han-Tani uses 0.6 of the price as what remains after Steam, VAT and refunds. On a $20 game that is 0.10 x $20 x 0.6 = $1.20 per wishlist in launch week, by our arithmetic.

Sources: Green Man Gaming (24 February 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025); Melos Han-Tani (12 April 2026).

How do I measure effective cost per wishlist in Manalens?

Sync daily wishlist adds with a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access), and import the Steam UTM report. Then you see all wishlist adds per day next to the UTM wishlists by campaign. Manalens does not import ad spend or compute lift, so divide your own spend by the lift in a sheet.

Sources: Manalens Steam documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Is effective cost per wishlist the same as incremental cost per wishlist?

In practice, yes. Both divide spend by the wishlists the campaign likely added, which you estimate as the wishlist adds in the campaign window minus a baseline. The tracked cost per wishlist divides by the UTM wishlists only, so it is usually higher.

Why is my effective cost per wishlist lower than my UTM cost?

Because the UTM report counts only signed-in players who wishlist within 72 hours of a tagged click in the same browser. In one Green Man Gaming campaign, it saw 24% of the wishlists. For Glyphica, the tracked cost was $5.49 and the effective cost was $3.14.

When does the effective cost per wishlist go wrong?

When something else happens in the same window, such as a Steam sale, a festival or a creator video. Then the lift also counts those wishlists, and the effective cost looks too low. Pick a quiet window, and note any other beat next to the result.

Sources and implementation