How do I split paid and organic wishlists?
Start with the organic baseline: your average daily wishlist adds in a quiet period with no paid campaign. Then paid wishlists = wishlist adds in the campaign window minus the baseline for the same number of days. The paid share is paid wishlists divided by all wishlist adds in the window.
The Steam UTM report gives a second, lower count: the wishlists from tagged paid links within 72 hours of a click. Use it to compare ads with each other, and the lift to size the whole paid effect.
Sources: Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024); Steamworks Wishlists and UTM Analytics documentation.
What does a worked example look like?
Example: before its Reddit ads, Glyphica had 227 wishlists in the control week from 19 to 26 May 2024, about 28 a day. In the ad week it had 386, about 55 a day. The difference of 159 is the paid estimate, and the rest is organic.
Our arithmetic: 159 / 386 = 41% of the ad week wishlists were paid. Steam UTM attributed only 91 of them, so the tracked paid share would be 91 / 386 = 24%.
Sources: Squeaky Wheel (21 June 2024).
Why do paid vs organic wishlists matter for indie PC and web games?
Because they may not buy at the same rate. After the Danchi Days launch, Melos Han-Tani rated wishlist types by how well they converted, with announcement period wishlists as 100. He rated organic wishlists 40 and ad clickers 15, the lowest of all. These are his judgment from one game, not a benchmark.
GameDiscoverCo also quoted the Furnish Master developer: wishlists from ads were of worse quality and converted less well. So divide cost per wishlist by the expected conversion of each source to get a cost per buyer before you scale a channel.
Sources: Melos Han-Tani (8 November 2026); GameDiscoverCo (17 October 2025).
How do I measure paid vs organic wishlists in Manalens?
Sync all daily wishlist adds with a Steamworks Financial API key (the automatic Steam sync is in early access), and import the Steam UTM report to see wishlists by source and campaign. Mark your campaign days, then compare the daily adds with your baseline. Spend is not imported, so keep it in your own sheet.
Sources: Manalens Steam documentation.
Frequently asked questions
Should I count organic wishlists when I compute cost per wishlist?
No. Count only the wishlists the paid channel brought: the UTM wishlists, or the lift over your organic baseline. If you divide spend by all wishlists in the window, organic wishlists make the paid channel look cheaper than it is.
Do paid wishlists convert worse than organic ones?
In the cases that are public, yes. The Danchi Days developer rated ad clickers at 15 against 40 for organic wishlists, with announcement wishlists at 100. GameDiscoverCo quoted the Furnish Master developer saying ad wishlists converted less well. Check your own data after launch.
How do I estimate my organic baseline?
Take your average daily wishlist adds in a quiet period with no paid campaign, such as the week before the ads. Glyphica had 227 wishlists in its control week from 19 to 26 May 2024, about 28 a day. Avoid periods with a Steam sale, a festival or a creator video.
Sources and implementation
- Squeaky Wheel: How many wishlists can $500 worth of Reddit ads get you? (Ryan Sumo, 21 June 2024) ↗
- Melos Han-Tani: Wishlist woes and post-cozy problems, Danchi Days (8 November 2026) ↗
- GameDiscoverCo: The state of Steam wishlist 'conversions': 2024-2025 (Simon Carless, 17 October 2025) ↗
- Steamworks documentation: Wishlists (Valve, read 18 November 2026) ↗
- Steamworks documentation: UTM Analytics (Valve, read 18 November 2026) ↗